The Role of the Indonesian Constitutional Court for An Effective Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Adjudication
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev114Keywords:
justiciable rights, constitutional rights, constitutional mandates, ecosoc rightsAbstract
The Indonesian Constitutional Court has played important roles and functions to protect and fulfill human rights in the Indonesian legal system including the economic, social and cultural rights through its legal power of judicial review. It affirms that the ecosoc rights are legal justiciable rights and they are parts of constitutional mandates. It means that decision on judicial reviews require State to behave in accordance to legal thresholds decided by the Court. Undoubtedly, compliance to the decisions will reveal undeniable facts for fulfilment of state conduct. However, it seems that there are still many considerations, emphasis and excuse to somehow reduce or ignore threshold of application of the Court decisions. Complexity of actors, institutions, authorities, level of implementation, and orientation of particular policies, programs, actions and funds reduces the thresholds.References
Books
Abarquez, Imelda, and Murshed, 2005, Community-based Disaster Risk Management: Field Practitioners' Handbook, ADPC.
Asshiddiqie, Jimly, 2008, Menuju Negara Hukum yang Demokratis, Jakarta: Setjen Kepaniteraan MK RI.
Ballentine, K., and Nitzschke, H., (Eds), 2005, Pro.ftting from Peace: Managing Resource Dimension of Civil Wars, Lynne Publisher.
Bello, 2004, Dark Victory: The United States Structural Adjustment and Global Poverty, Pluto Press, London;
Burgstaller, Markus, 2005, Theories of Compliance with International Law, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Conforti, Bennedotto, 1997, “National Court and the International Law of Human Rights", in Bennedotto Conforti and Francesco Francioni (eds), Enforcing International Human Rights in Domestic Court.
D. Hunter, 2002, International Environmental Law and Policy, Foundation Press, New York.
Eide, Absjorn (et.all), 1995, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, A Textbook.
El Zeidy, Mohamed M, 2008, The Principle of Complementarity in International Criminal Law: Origin, Development and Practice, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Flamholtz, E.G, Das, T.K., & A.S. Tsui, 1985, Toward an Integrative Framework of Organizational Control, Accounting, Organization and Society.
Giddens,1998, A. The Third Way of Social Democracy.
Geraldine Van Bueren, 1995, The International law on the Rights of Child. George, 1998, A Fate Worse Than Debt, Penguin, Harmondswoth.
Guzman, Andrew, 2008, How International Law Works: A Rational Choice Theory, Oxford University Press.
Hodgson., R.L.P, 1993, Community Participation in Emergency Technical Assistance Programmes: Technical Support for Refugees.
Kasim, Ifdal and Johanes Masenus Arus, 2001, Hak Ekonomi, Sosial dan Budaya, Essay-Esay Pilihan, Buku 2, ELSAM.
Kepaniteraan dan Sekretaris Jenderal MK, 2013, Model dan Implementasi Keputusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Dalam Pengujian Undang-Undang: Studi Putusan Tahun 2003-2012, Pusat Penelitian dan Pengkajian Perkara, Setjen Mahkamah Konstitusi RI.
Otley, David, 1999, Management Accounting Research, “Performance Management: a Framework for Management Control System Research".
Phillip, Diana, 2015, “Humanitarian Assistance and the Right to Water: An ASEAN Region Perspective", in Anderj Zwitter, Chirstopher K. Lamont, Hans Joachim Heitze and Joost Herman, Humanitarian Action: Global, Regional and Domestic Legal Responses, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Porto, J.G.,1998, “Contemporary Conflict Analysis in Perspective" (Chapter One), in Lind, J., et all, Scarcity and Survive: The Ecology of Africa's Conflict, ACTS, Kenya;
Ribot, J.C, 1990. “Accountable Representation and Power Participation and Decentralized Environmental Management", Unasylva 1999, Volume 50.
Steiner, Henry J, and Phillip Alston, 2000, International Human Rights in Context Law Politics Morals, Oxford 2nd ed.
Journals
Dixon, H. “Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict Evidence from Cases", International Security, Volume 19, Number 1, 1994.
Doherty, K.L., and Timothy L.H. McCormack, 1999, “Complementarity as a Catalyst for Comprehensive Domestic Penal Legislation', 5 U.C Davis Journal of International Law and Policy.
Kleffner, Jann K., 2003, “The Impact of Complementarity on National Implementation of Substantive International Criminal Law, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 1.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1999, “Legal, Economic and Political Objectives of National and International Competition Policies: Constitutional Functions of WTO “Linking Principles" for Trade and Competition", 34 New England Law Review.
Petersman, Ulrich, 2001, “Human Rights and International Economic Law in the 21st Century: The Need to Clarify Their Interrelationship", 4 Journal of International Economic Law.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1996, “Constitutionalism and International Organization", 17 Northwestern Journal of International Business.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1999, “How to Constitutionalize International Law and Foreign Policy for the Benefit of Civil Society?", 20 Michigan Journal of International Law.
Sakai, M. “Konflik Sekitar Devolusi Kekuasaan Ekonomi dan Politik: Suatu Pengantar", Antropologi Indonesia, Volume 68, 2002.
Susiloadi, P. “Konsep dan Isu Desentralisasi Dalam Manajemen Pemerintahan di Indonesia”, Spirit Publik, Volume 3, Number 2 October 2007.
Tobin, John, “Seeking Clarity in Relation to the Principle of Complementarity: Reflection on The Recent Contributions of Some International Bodies" Melbourne Jounal of International Law, Volume 8, 2007.
Triatmodjo., M. “Anatomi Hukum Lingkungan Internasional, Sistem Generik Penyangga Kehidupan Umat Manusia", Jurnal Mimbar Hukum, No. 34/II/2000.
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, “The Implementation of the International Norms on Disaster Response in Indonesia", KLRI Journal of Law and Legislation, Volume 3, Number 1, Korean Legislative Research Institute, 2013.
Triyana, Heribesrtus Jaka, “Komentar Hukum Mengenai Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Perkara Nomor 012/PUU-III/2005 Menganai Pengujian UU No. 36 Tahun 2004 Tentang APBN Dalam Kaitannya Dengan Hak Asasi Manusia", Warta Pendidikan, Setjen Kemdikbud, Vol. 2, No. 1, Tahun 2006.
Venning, Philipa, Determination of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights by the Indonesian Contitutional Court, Australia Journal of Asian Law, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2008 excerted by Konsitusi, Number 88, June 2014.
Walter W. McMahon, Boediono and Abas Gazali, “A New View of Manpower Supplies and Demand in Indonesia: The Need to Use Market Signals and Labor Analysis", BP3K Departemen Pendidikan Dan Kebudayaan Indonesia, 1991.
Jurisprudence Cases
A v UK (Application) No. 15599/1994, Report of 18 September 1997, para 48;
Artico v Italy, European Court of Human Rights (1980) Series A.No. 37, 16;
Loizidou v Turkey (Preliminary Objections), European Court of Human Rights (1995) Series A.No.310, 23 February 1995, para. 72';
Velasquez-Rodriquez (Judgment), 29 July 1988, Inter American Court of Human Rights (1988) Series C. No.4, para 167;
Papers dan Proceedings
Asshiddiqqi, J. “Otonomi Daerah dan Peluang Investasi, Paper on Government Conference on Peluang Investasi dan Otonomi Daerah", September 30th 2000, Jakarta.
Baiquni, M. and Rijanta, R.. Konflik Pengelolaan Lingkungan dan Sumber Daya Dalam Era Otonomi dan Transisi Masyarakat, Paper, 2007.
Christanto, J. “Otonomi Daerah dan Skenario Indonesia 2010 Dalam Konteks Pembangunan Daerah Pendekatan Kewilayahan", Paper (unpublished).
Eddyono, Luthfi Widagdo, and Mardian Wibowo, “The Fist Ten Year of the Connstitutional Court of Indonesia: The Establishment of the Principle of Equality and the Prohibition of Discrimonation", The 1st Summer School of the Association of Asian Constitutional Court and Equivalent Institutions, Ankara, 6-13 October 2013.
Faiz, Pan Mohamad", 2007, “Quo Vadis Sistem Pendidikan Nasional, Analisis Kritis Putusan Jilid I, Judicial Review Undang-Undang Sisdiknas, tidak dipublikasikan.
Orford., A, 2000, ‘The Subject of Globalization: Economics, Identity and Human Rights" in Proceedings of the 94th Annual Meeting of the American Society of International Law.
Situmorang, Ecoline, “Judicial Review Undang Nomor 25 Tahun 2007 Tentang Penanaman Modal", Workshop Memperkuat Justiciabilitas Hak Ekonomi, Sosial dan Budaya, Yogyakarta, 13-17 November 2007;
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, 2008, “Legal Aspects of the Maritime Delineation in the Archipelagic Riau Province", Draft of the Maritime Spatial Planning, the Center of Regional Development, Gadjah Mada University.
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, 2007, “Pemenuhan Hak Atas Pendidikan dan Kesahatan dalam Kerangka Desentralisasi Daerah di Indonesia", Penelitian FH UGM didanai oleh Unit Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat FH UGM.
Triyana, Heribertus, Jaka, “Legal Aspects of the Current Spatial Planning", Review Presented on the Workshop with the People Assembly Working Group, Bandung, on November 23rd 2006,
Wetherall, Anthony, 2005, Normative Rule Making at the IAEA: Codes of Conduct, Paper, Unpublished.
Abarquez, Imelda, and Murshed, 2005, Community-based Disaster Risk Management: Field Practitioners' Handbook, ADPC.
Asshiddiqie, Jimly, 2008, Menuju Negara Hukum yang Demokratis, Jakarta: Setjen Kepaniteraan MK RI.
Ballentine, K., and Nitzschke, H., (Eds), 2005, Pro.ftting from Peace: Managing Resource Dimension of Civil Wars, Lynne Publisher.
Bello, 2004, Dark Victory: The United States Structural Adjustment and Global Poverty, Pluto Press, London;
Burgstaller, Markus, 2005, Theories of Compliance with International Law, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Conforti, Bennedotto, 1997, “National Court and the International Law of Human Rights", in Bennedotto Conforti and Francesco Francioni (eds), Enforcing International Human Rights in Domestic Court.
D. Hunter, 2002, International Environmental Law and Policy, Foundation Press, New York.
Eide, Absjorn (et.all), 1995, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, A Textbook.
El Zeidy, Mohamed M, 2008, The Principle of Complementarity in International Criminal Law: Origin, Development and Practice, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Flamholtz, E.G, Das, T.K., & A.S. Tsui, 1985, Toward an Integrative Framework of Organizational Control, Accounting, Organization and Society.
Giddens,1998, A. The Third Way of Social Democracy.
Geraldine Van Bueren, 1995, The International law on the Rights of Child. George, 1998, A Fate Worse Than Debt, Penguin, Harmondswoth.
Guzman, Andrew, 2008, How International Law Works: A Rational Choice Theory, Oxford University Press.
Hodgson., R.L.P, 1993, Community Participation in Emergency Technical Assistance Programmes: Technical Support for Refugees.
Kasim, Ifdal and Johanes Masenus Arus, 2001, Hak Ekonomi, Sosial dan Budaya, Essay-Esay Pilihan, Buku 2, ELSAM.
Kepaniteraan dan Sekretaris Jenderal MK, 2013, Model dan Implementasi Keputusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Dalam Pengujian Undang-Undang: Studi Putusan Tahun 2003-2012, Pusat Penelitian dan Pengkajian Perkara, Setjen Mahkamah Konstitusi RI.
Otley, David, 1999, Management Accounting Research, “Performance Management: a Framework for Management Control System Research".
Phillip, Diana, 2015, “Humanitarian Assistance and the Right to Water: An ASEAN Region Perspective", in Anderj Zwitter, Chirstopher K. Lamont, Hans Joachim Heitze and Joost Herman, Humanitarian Action: Global, Regional and Domestic Legal Responses, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Porto, J.G.,1998, “Contemporary Conflict Analysis in Perspective" (Chapter One), in Lind, J., et all, Scarcity and Survive: The Ecology of Africa's Conflict, ACTS, Kenya;
Ribot, J.C, 1990. “Accountable Representation and Power Participation and Decentralized Environmental Management", Unasylva 1999, Volume 50.
Steiner, Henry J, and Phillip Alston, 2000, International Human Rights in Context Law Politics Morals, Oxford 2nd ed.
Journals
Dixon, H. “Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict Evidence from Cases", International Security, Volume 19, Number 1, 1994.
Doherty, K.L., and Timothy L.H. McCormack, 1999, “Complementarity as a Catalyst for Comprehensive Domestic Penal Legislation', 5 U.C Davis Journal of International Law and Policy.
Kleffner, Jann K., 2003, “The Impact of Complementarity on National Implementation of Substantive International Criminal Law, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 1.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1999, “Legal, Economic and Political Objectives of National and International Competition Policies: Constitutional Functions of WTO “Linking Principles" for Trade and Competition", 34 New England Law Review.
Petersman, Ulrich, 2001, “Human Rights and International Economic Law in the 21st Century: The Need to Clarify Their Interrelationship", 4 Journal of International Economic Law.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1996, “Constitutionalism and International Organization", 17 Northwestern Journal of International Business.
Petersman, Ulrich, 1999, “How to Constitutionalize International Law and Foreign Policy for the Benefit of Civil Society?", 20 Michigan Journal of International Law.
Sakai, M. “Konflik Sekitar Devolusi Kekuasaan Ekonomi dan Politik: Suatu Pengantar", Antropologi Indonesia, Volume 68, 2002.
Susiloadi, P. “Konsep dan Isu Desentralisasi Dalam Manajemen Pemerintahan di Indonesia”, Spirit Publik, Volume 3, Number 2 October 2007.
Tobin, John, “Seeking Clarity in Relation to the Principle of Complementarity: Reflection on The Recent Contributions of Some International Bodies" Melbourne Jounal of International Law, Volume 8, 2007.
Triatmodjo., M. “Anatomi Hukum Lingkungan Internasional, Sistem Generik Penyangga Kehidupan Umat Manusia", Jurnal Mimbar Hukum, No. 34/II/2000.
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, “The Implementation of the International Norms on Disaster Response in Indonesia", KLRI Journal of Law and Legislation, Volume 3, Number 1, Korean Legislative Research Institute, 2013.
Triyana, Heribesrtus Jaka, “Komentar Hukum Mengenai Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Perkara Nomor 012/PUU-III/2005 Menganai Pengujian UU No. 36 Tahun 2004 Tentang APBN Dalam Kaitannya Dengan Hak Asasi Manusia", Warta Pendidikan, Setjen Kemdikbud, Vol. 2, No. 1, Tahun 2006.
Venning, Philipa, Determination of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights by the Indonesian Contitutional Court, Australia Journal of Asian Law, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2008 excerted by Konsitusi, Number 88, June 2014.
Walter W. McMahon, Boediono and Abas Gazali, “A New View of Manpower Supplies and Demand in Indonesia: The Need to Use Market Signals and Labor Analysis", BP3K Departemen Pendidikan Dan Kebudayaan Indonesia, 1991.
Jurisprudence Cases
A v UK (Application) No. 15599/1994, Report of 18 September 1997, para 48;
Artico v Italy, European Court of Human Rights (1980) Series A.No. 37, 16;
Loizidou v Turkey (Preliminary Objections), European Court of Human Rights (1995) Series A.No.310, 23 February 1995, para. 72';
Velasquez-Rodriquez (Judgment), 29 July 1988, Inter American Court of Human Rights (1988) Series C. No.4, para 167;
Papers dan Proceedings
Asshiddiqqi, J. “Otonomi Daerah dan Peluang Investasi, Paper on Government Conference on Peluang Investasi dan Otonomi Daerah", September 30th 2000, Jakarta.
Baiquni, M. and Rijanta, R.. Konflik Pengelolaan Lingkungan dan Sumber Daya Dalam Era Otonomi dan Transisi Masyarakat, Paper, 2007.
Christanto, J. “Otonomi Daerah dan Skenario Indonesia 2010 Dalam Konteks Pembangunan Daerah Pendekatan Kewilayahan", Paper (unpublished).
Eddyono, Luthfi Widagdo, and Mardian Wibowo, “The Fist Ten Year of the Connstitutional Court of Indonesia: The Establishment of the Principle of Equality and the Prohibition of Discrimonation", The 1st Summer School of the Association of Asian Constitutional Court and Equivalent Institutions, Ankara, 6-13 October 2013.
Faiz, Pan Mohamad", 2007, “Quo Vadis Sistem Pendidikan Nasional, Analisis Kritis Putusan Jilid I, Judicial Review Undang-Undang Sisdiknas, tidak dipublikasikan.
Orford., A, 2000, ‘The Subject of Globalization: Economics, Identity and Human Rights" in Proceedings of the 94th Annual Meeting of the American Society of International Law.
Situmorang, Ecoline, “Judicial Review Undang Nomor 25 Tahun 2007 Tentang Penanaman Modal", Workshop Memperkuat Justiciabilitas Hak Ekonomi, Sosial dan Budaya, Yogyakarta, 13-17 November 2007;
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, 2008, “Legal Aspects of the Maritime Delineation in the Archipelagic Riau Province", Draft of the Maritime Spatial Planning, the Center of Regional Development, Gadjah Mada University.
Triyana, Heribertus Jaka, 2007, “Pemenuhan Hak Atas Pendidikan dan Kesahatan dalam Kerangka Desentralisasi Daerah di Indonesia", Penelitian FH UGM didanai oleh Unit Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat FH UGM.
Triyana, Heribertus, Jaka, “Legal Aspects of the Current Spatial Planning", Review Presented on the Workshop with the People Assembly Working Group, Bandung, on November 23rd 2006,
Wetherall, Anthony, 2005, Normative Rule Making at the IAEA: Codes of Conduct, Paper, Unpublished.
Downloads
Published
2016-03-28
How to Cite
Triyana, H. J. (2016). The Role of the Indonesian Constitutional Court for An Effective Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Adjudication. Constitutional Review, 1(1), 72–102. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev114
Issue
Section
Articles
