The Removal of the Constitutional Chamber Justices in El Salvador: A Story About the Fragility of Judicial Independence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev1025Keywords:
Constitutional Authoritarian-Populism, Constitutional Chamber, Judicial Independence, Presidential Re-election, RemovalAbstract
The work discusses a significant event that occurred on May 1, 2021, when the Legislative Assembly of El Salvador removed the Justices of the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice before their term expiration, violating legal procedures. This action was facilitated by a combination of populist rhetoric from the President and abuse of power by the Legislative Assembly. Referred to as Constitutional Authoritarian-Populism, this trend undermines the rule of law. The text outlines the Salvadoran constitutional framework and discusses concepts like judicial independence, populism, abusive constitutionalism, and authoritarianism in the Latin American context. It then examines instances of Constitutional Authoritarian-Populism in El Salvador from 2019 to 2023, demonstrating that the removal of the Justices wasn’t spontaneous. Finally, it analyzes the process of removal, the response from the removed Justices, and the subsequent decision by newly appointed Justices to authorize presidential re-election in El Salvador.
References
Asamblea Legislativa. “Asamblea Legislativa destituye al Fiscal General de la República por vinculación partidaria [Legislative Assembly Dismisses the Attorney General of the Republic Due to Party Affiliation].” Asamblea Legislativa, May 8, 2021. https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/node/11225#:~:text=Con%2064%20votos%20a%20favor,de%20la%20Rep%C3%BAblica%2C%20Ra%C3%BAl%20Melara.&text=nueva%20Asamblea%20Legislativa,Con%2064%20votos%20a%20favor%2C%20los%20diputados%20de%20la%20Asamblea,de%20la%20Rep%C3%BAblica%2C%20Ra%C3%BAl%20Melara.
Asamblea Legislativa. “Régimen de excepción se extenderá por otros 30 días [State of Exception Will Be Extended for Another 30 Days].” Asamblea Legislativa, June 14, 2023. https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/node/12821.
BBC News Mundo. “Coronavirus en El Salvador: a polémica por la negativa de Bukele a acatar la orden de la Corte Suprema que prohíbe ‘detenciones arbitrarias’ durante la cuarentena [Coronavirus in El Salvador: The Controversy Over Bukele’s Refusal to Comply with the Supreme Court’s Order Prohibiting ‘Arbitrary Detentions’ During Quarantine].” BBC News Mundo, April 16, 2020. https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias-america-latina-52319351.
Bernal Pulido, Carlos. “Constituciones sin constitucionalismo y la desproporción de la proporcionalidad. Dos aspectos de la encrucijada de los derechos fundamentales en el neoconstitucionalismo [Constitutions without Constitutionalism and the Disproportionality of Proportionality: Two Aspects of the Dilemma of Fundamental Rights in Neoconstitutionalism].” Fundamentos: Cuadernos monográficos de teoría del estado, derecho público e historia constitucional, no. 9 (2016): 39–70. https://www.unioviedo.es/constitucional/fundamentos/noveno/pdfs/03_carlosbernal.pdf.
CNN Español. “Qué países tienen las tasas de homicidios más altas del mundo? El Salvador, entre los que encabezan la lista [Which Countries Have the Highest Homicide Rates in the World? El Salvador Is Among the Top].” CNN Español, May 18, 2022. https://cnnespanol.cnn.com/2022/05/18/paises-tasas-homicidios-altas-mundo-salvador-encabezan-la-lista-orix/.
CNN Español. “Aprueban ley para jubilar a jueces y fiscales a los 60 años en El Salvador [Law Approved to Retire Judges and Prosecutors at the Age of 60 in El Salvador].” CNN Español, September 1, 2021. https://cnnespanol.cnn.com/2021/09/01/aprueban-ley-para-jubilar-a-jueces-y-fiscales-a-los-60-anos-en-el-salvador/.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 16-2011. April 27, 2011.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 56-2016. November 25, 2016.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 21-2020/23-2020/24-2020/25-2020. June 8, 2020.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Habeas Corpus 148-2020. March 26, 2020.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 61-2009. July 29, 2010.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 7-2012. December 16, 2013.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 33-2015. November 24, 2017.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 1-2017/25-2017. July 26, 2017.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 122-2014. April 28, 2015.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Amparo 713-2015. September 1, 2016.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Amparo 934-2007. March 4, 2011.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Habeas Corpus 119-2014 ac. May 27, 2016.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 44-2013/145-2013. July 13, 2016.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 33-2015. July 13, 2016.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Amparo 166-2009. September 21, 2011.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Amparo 701-2016. July 2, 2018.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Unconstitutionality 163-2013. June 25, 2014.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Pérdida de los derechos de ciudadanía [Loss of Political Rights] 1-2021. September 3, 2021.
Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of El Salvador. Judgment of Mandamiento Judicial de Inconstitucionalidad [Judicial Order of
Unconstitutionality] 1-2021. May 1, 2021.
da Silva, José Alfonso. Aplicabilidad de las normas constitucionales [Applicability of Constitutional Norms]. México: UNAM, 2003.
Europapress. “El Salvador cerrará 2015 como el año más violento de su historia, con más de 6.600 homicidios [El Salvador Will Close 2015 as the Most Violent Year in Its History, with Over 6,600 Homicides].” Europapress, December 30, 2015. https://www.europapress.es/internacional/noticia-salvador-cerrara-2015-ano-mas-violento-historia-mas-6600-homicidios-20151230032319.html.
Fiscalía General de la República. “Fiscalía salda deuda histórica al intervenir diferentes propiedades del expresidente Cristiani [Prosecution
Settles Historic Debt by Intervening in Various Properties of Former President Cristiani].” Fiscalía General de la República, June 2, 2023.
Fiss, Owen M. “The Limits of Judicial Independence.” The University of Miami Inter-American Law Review 25, no. 1 (1993): 57–76. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40176330.
Gargarella, Roberto, and Jorge Ernesto Roa Roa. “Diálogo democrático y emergencia en América Latina [Democratic Dialogue and Emergency in Latin America].” MPIL Research Paper Series No. 2020-21 (2020): 1–30. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3623812.
González Bonilla, Rodolfo Ernesto. “Cualidades de la Constitución [Qualities of the Constitution].” In Teoría de la Constitución. Estudios en Homenaje a José Albino Tinetti, 109–132. San Salvador: Corte Suprema de Justicia, 2020.
Guzmán, Valeria, et al. “Bukele mete al Ejército en la Asamblea y amenaza con disolverla dentro de una semana [Bukele Sends the Army into the Legislative Assembly and Threatens to Dissolve It Within a Week].” El Faro, February 10, 2020. https://elfaro.net/es/202002/el_salvador/24008/Bukele-mete-al-Ej%C3%A9rcito-en-la-Asamblea-y-amenaza-con-disolverla-dentro-de-una-semana.htm.
Hamilton, Alexander. “The Federalist Papers: No. 78 and 79.” United States: Library of Congress. Accessed June 21, 2023. https://guides.loc.gov/federalist-papers/full-text.
Hernández G., José Ignacio. “The Constitutional Chamber in El Salvador and Presidential Re-election: Another Case of Constitutional Authoritarian-Populism.” Int’l J. Const. L. Blog, September 10, 2021. http://www.iconnectblog.com/2021/09/the-constitutional-chamber-in-el-salvador-and-presidential-reelection-another-case-of-constitutional-authoritarian-populism/.
Human Rights Watch. “El Salvador: Abusos Policiales en la Respuesta a la Covid-19 [El Salvador: Police Abuses in Response to COVID-19].” Human Rights Watch , April 15, 2020. https://www.hrw.org/es/news/2020/04/15/el-salvador-abusos-policiales-en-la-respuesta-la-covid-19.
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. “CIDH llama a El Salvador a restablecer los derechos y garantías suspendidos hace un año por el régimen de excepción [The IACHR Calls on El Salvador to Restore the Rights and Guarantees Suspended a Year Ago Under the State of Emergency].” April 6, 2023. https://w w w.oas.org/es/CIDH/jsForm/?File=/es/cidh/prensa/comunicados/2023/058.asp
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Acosta y otros vs. Nicaragua. March 25, 2017.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Apitz Barbera y otros (“Corte Primera de lo Contencioso Administrativo”) vs. Venezuela. August 5, 2008. Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Argüelles y otros vs. Argentina. November 20, 2014.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Chocrón Chocrón vs. Venezuela. July 1, 2011.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Colindres Schonenberg vs. El Salvador. February 4, 2019.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Cordero Bernal vs. Perú. February 16, 2021.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Corte Suprema de Justicia (Quintana Coello y otros) vs. Ecuador. August 23, 2013.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Cuya Lavy y otros vs. Perú. September 28, 2021.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. López Lone y otros vs. Honduras. October 5, 2015.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Moya Solís vs. Perú. June 3, 2021.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Palamara Iribarne vs. Chile. November 22, 2005.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Reverón Trujillo vs. Venezuela. June 30, 2009.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Rico vs. Argentina. September 2, 2019.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Ríos Avalos y otro vs. Paraguay. August 19, 2021.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. San Miguel Sosa y otras vs. Venezuela. February 8, 2018.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Tribunal Constitucional (Camba Campos y otros) vs. Ecuador. August 28, 2013.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Tribunal Constitucional vs. Perú. January 31, 2001.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Villaseñor Velarde y otros vs. Guatemala. February 5, 2019.
Inter-American Court on Human Rights. Opiniones Consultivas [Advisory Opinions] OC-8/87, January 30, 1987, and OC-28/21, June 7, 2021.
La Prensa Gráfica. “Los cuatro expresidentes salvadoreños señalados por la justicia [The Four Former Salvadoran Presidents Indicted by the Justice System].” La Prensa Gráf ica, August 24, 2021. https://www.laprensagrafica.com/elsalvador/Los-cuatro-expresidentes-salvadorenos-senalados-por-la-justicia-20210824-0051.html.
Landau, David. “Abusive Constitutionalism.” Davis Law Review 47, no. 1 (2013): 189–260.
Loughlin, Martin. Against Constitutionalism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2022.
Macho Carro, Alberto. “De la dificultad contramayoritaria al diálogo interinstitucional: mecanismos de equilibrio en la relación justicia constitucional–poder legislativo [From the Counter-majoritarian Difficulty to Inter-Institutional Dialogue: Mechanisms of Balance in the Relationship Between Constitutional Justice and the Legislative Power].” Anuario Iberoamericano de Justicia Constitucional 1, no. 23 (2019): 231–260.
Marmor, Andrei. “Constitutionalism, Liberalism and Democracy.” In Constitutionalism: Old Dilemmas, New Insights. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 2021. Martínez, Carlos. “Pandillas admiten por primera vez que negociaron tregua con el Ejecutivo [Gangs Admit for the First Time That They Negotiated a Truce With the Executive].” El Faro, May 30, 2016. https://elfaro.net/es/206005/el_salvador/18665/Pandillas-admiten-por-primera-vez-que-negociaron-tregua-con-el-Ejecutivo.htm.
Martínez, Óscar, etal. “Gobierno negoció con pandillas reducción de homicidios [Government Negotiateda Reduction of Homicides With Gangs].” El Faro, March 14, 2012. https://www.elfaro.net/es/201203/noticias/7985/Gobierno-negoci%97-con-pandillas-reducci%97n-de-homicidios.htm.
Menjívar, Manuel Adrián Merino. “El control judicial de las reformas constitucionales en El Salvador: Un control a medias? [Judicial Review of
Constitutional Amendments in El Salvador: A Halfway Review?].” UDA Law Review 4 (2022): 45–53. https://prisma.uazuay.edu.ec/index.php/
udalawreview/article/view/611.
Menjívar, Manuel Adrián Merino. “El Salvador.” In The 2021 Global Review of Constitutional Law, November 2022. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4285035.
Menjívar, Manuel Adrián Merino. “When Judges Unbound Ulysses: The Case of Presidential Reelection in El Salvador.” Int’l J. Const. L. Blog, September 9, 2021. http://www.iconnectblog.com/2021/09/when-judges-unbound-ulysses-the-case-of-presidential-reelection-in-el-salvador/.
Moffitt, Benjamin. Populismo. Guía para entender la palabra clave de la política contemporánea [Populism: A Guide to Understanding the Keyword of Contemporary Politics]. Argentina: Siglo Veintiuno Editores, 2022.
Montesquieu. El espíritu de las leyes [The Spirit of the Laws]. Tomo I. Madrid: Librería General de Victoriano Suárez, 1906.
Mudde, Cas, and Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser. Populism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017.
Roa Roa, Jorge Ernesto. “No(s) representan los jueces constitucionales? [Do Constitutional Judges Represent Us?].” In Democracia, representación y nuevas formas de participación: una mirada en prospectiva. XXI Jornadas de Derecho Constitucional. Constitucionalismo en transformación. Prospectiva 2030, 274–305. Bogotá: Universidad Externado de Colombia, 2021.
Romero, Fernando. “El nuevo fiscal…inconstitucional [The New Attorney… Unconstitutional].” Factum, December 26, 2018. https://www.revistafactum.com/el-nuevo-fiscal-inconstitucional/.
Roznai, Yaniv. Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments: The Limits of Amendment Powers. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Salmorán Villar, Guadalupe. Populismo. Historia y geografía de un concepto [Populism: History and Geography of a Concept]. México: UNAM, 2021.
Sarmiento Erazo, Juan Pablo. “Populismo constitucional y reelecciones, vicisitudes institucionales en la experiencia suamericana [Constitutional Populism and Re-Elections, Institutional Vicissitudes in the South American Experience].” Estudios Constitucionales no. 1 (2013): 569–602. http://www.estudiosconstitucionales.cl/index.php/econstitucionales/article/view/71.
Segura, Edwin. “Bukele arranca 2023 con 91% de aprobación [Bukele Starts 2023 with a 91% Approval Rating].” LPG Datos, March 15, 2023. https://www.laprensagrafica.com/lpgdatos/LPG-Datos--Bukele-arranca-2023-con-91--de-aprobacion-20230314-0090.html.
Sermeño, H., and Eugenia Velásquez. “Bukele contra la Sala: Si fuera un dictador, los hubiera fusilado a todos. Salvas mil vidas a cambio de cinco [Bukele Against the Chamber: If I Were a Dictator, I Would Have Shot Them All. You Save a Thousand Lives at the Cost of Five].” elsalvador.com, August 10, 2020. https://historico.elsalvador.com/historico/740872/nayib-bukele-ataque-sala-de-lo-constitucional-dictador.html.
The Commission on the Truth for El Salvador. From Madness to Hope: The 12-Year War in El Salvador: Report of the Commission on the Truth for
El Salvador. United States Institute of Peace. Accessed June 14, 2023. https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/file/ElSalvador-Report.pdf.
Urbinati, Nadia. Yo, el pueblo. Cómo el populismo transforma la democracia [Me the People: How Populism Transforms Democracy]. México: Instituto Nacional Electoral-Grano de Sal, 2020.
Valencia, Roberto. “El Salvador, el país más violento de América: un asesinato cada 2 horas [El Salvador, the Most Violent Country in America: One Murder Every 2 Hours].” El Mundo.es, January 3, 2010. https://www.elmundo.es/america/2010/01/03/noticias/1262538114.html.
Vela Ávalos, Marcos Antonio. “Justicia dialógica en una ingeniería constitucional resistente al constitucionalismo dialógico: El caso de El Salvador [Dialogic Justice in a Constitutional Engineering Resistant to Dialogic Constitutionalism: The Case of El Salvador].” Anuario Iberoamericano de Justicia Constitucional 26, no. 1 (2022): 181–211. https://doi.org/10.18042/cepc/aijc.26.07.
Viciano Pastor, Roberto, and Gabriel Moreno González. “Cuando los jueces declaran inconstitucional la Constitución: la reelección presidencial en América Latina a la luz de las últimas decisiones de las Cortes Constitucionales [When Judges Declare the Constitution Unconstitutional: Presidential Re-Election in Latin America in Light of the Latest Decisions of the Constitutional Courts].” Anuario Iberoamericano de Justicia Constitucional no. 22 (2018): 165–198. https://doi.org/10.18042/cepc/aijc.22.06.
