Economic, Social and Cultural Rights During Crisis in Cyprus: The Interplay Between Domestic and External Normative Systems
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev714Keywords:
Cyprus, ECHR, Economic Crisis, Right to Property, Social and Cultural RightsAbstract
Economic, Social and Cultural (ESC) rights have been present and active in the Cypriot legal order from the moment of its constitutional genesis. Due to the special relationship between the Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), the judiciary has adopted a unique approach when interpreting the Constitution; it has been willing to engage into a comparative juridical analysis and to rely on the ECHR and the findings of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECtHR). Through this nexus with the ECHR and the streamlined approach with the ECtHR, the legal system of Cyprus has been progressive in placing social and economic rights – and to a lesser extent cultural rights – in a secure position. This traditional approach of the Cypriot courts was called into question by the 2011-2016 economic crisis, which challenged the interplay between domestic and external normative systems. The aim of this paper is to assess the impact of the recent economic crisis on the protection of ESC rights and the change in the balance between domestic and normative systems. The analysis concludes that the protection of ESC rights under the Cypriot Constitution, as formed by Cypriot case law, has been substantive and effective, while positively influenced by the extensive deployment of the comparative method. That long-standing approach has been challenged by the economic crisis and it seems that the extrovert judicial viewpoint is now partly reconsidered. The Supreme Court has indicated, albeit in specific instances, its willingness to disregard guidance from external influences and to focus instead on the idea that national constitutional protection can and should exceed that of the ECHR.
References
Alfredsson, Gudmundur. “Article 17.” In The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: A Commentary, edited by A. Eide, et al. 255-62. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press, 1993.
An-Na’im, Abdullahi Ahmed. “To Affirm the Full Human Rights Standing of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.” In Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Practice: The Role of Judges in Implementing Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, edited by Yash Ghai and Jill Cottrell. 7-16. London: Interights, 2004.
Bilchitz, David. “Socio-Economic Rights, Economic Crisis, and Legal Doctrine.” International Journal of Constitutional Law 12, no. 3 (2014): 710-739.
De Smith, Stanley Alexander. The New Commonwealth and Its Constitutions. London: Stevens, 1964.
Douglas-Scott, Sionaidh. “The European Union and Human Rights after the Treaty of Lisbon.” Human Rights Law Review 11, no. 4 (2011).
Emilianides, Achilles C. Constitutional Law in Cyprus. Alphen aan der Rijn: Wolter Kluwer Law and Business, 2013.
Golay, Christophe and Ioana Cismas. “Legal Opinion: The Right to Property from a Human Rights Perspective.” Montreal: Rights and Democracy, 2010.
Howard-Hassmann, Rhoda E. “Reconsidering the Right to Own Property.” Journal of Human Rights 12, no. 2 (2013).
Kagiaros, Dimitrios. “Austerity Measures at the European Court of Human Rights: Can the Court Establish a Minimum of Welfare Provisions?” European Public Law 25, no. 4 (2019).
Kombos, Constantinos and Stéphanie Laulhé Shaelou. “The Cypriot Constitution Under the Impact of EU Law: An Asymmetrical Formation.” In National Constitutions in European and Global Governance: Democracy, Rights, the Rule of Law, edited by Albi, Anneli, Bardutzky, and Samo. 1373-1432. The Hague: Springer, 2019.
Kombos, Constantinos. “Constitutional Review and the Economic Crisis: In the Courts We Trust?” European Public Law 25, no. 1 (2019).
Kombos, Constantinos. “Constitutional Review and the Economic Crisis: In the Courts We Trust? - Part Two.” European Public Law 25, no. 2 (2019).
Kombos, Constantinos. “Social Rights in the Republic of Cyprus.” In Social and Economic Rights as Fundamental Rights, edited by Krzysztof Wojtyczek. 57-86. Utrecht: Eleven International Publishing, 2016.
Kombos, Constantinos. The Impact of EU Law on Cypriot Public Law. Athens: Sakkoulas, 2015.
Krause, Catarina and Gudmundur Alfredsson. “Article 17.” In The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: A Common Standard of Achievement, edited by G. Alfredsson and A. Eide. 359-378. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1999.
Kyriakou, Nikolas and Nurcan Kaya. “Minority Rights: Solutions to the Cyprus Conflict.” A Report, Minority Rights Group International, 2011.
Loizou, Andreas. Σύνταγμα Κυπριακής Δημοκρατίας [The Constitution of the Republic of Cyprus]. Nicosia: 2001.
Markides, Alecos. “The Republic of Cyprus.” In Constitutional Law of 10 EU Member States: The 2004 Enlargement, edited by C. Kortmann, et al. Deventer: Kluwer, 2006.
Papadopoulos, Nikolaos. “Austerity Measures in Greece and Social Rights Protection under the European Social Charter: Comment on CSEE v. Greece Case, Complaint No. 111/2014, European Committee of Social Rights, 5 July 2017.” European Labour Law Journal 10, no. 1 (2019).
Paraskeva, Costas. Κυπριακό Συνταγματικό Δίκαιο: Θεμελιώδη Δικαιώματα και Ελευθερίες [Cypriot Constitutional Law: Fundamental Rights and Liberties]. Athens: Nomiki Vivliothiki, 2015.
Pervou, Ioanna. “Human Rights in Times of Crisis: The Greek Cases before the ECtHR, or the Polarisation of a Democratic Society.” Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law 5, no. 1 (2016).
Petrou, Panagiotis and Sotiris Vandoros. “Healthcare reforms in Cyprus 2013–2017: Does the crisis mark the end of the healthcare sector as we know it?” Health Policy 122, no. 2 (2018).
Rosas, Allan. “Property Rights.” In The Strength of Diversity: Human Rights and Pluralist Democracy, edited by Allan Rosas, Jan Helgesen, and D. Goodman. 133-157. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1992.
Ssenyonjo, Manisuli. Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in International Law. Oxford: Hart, 2009.
Tornaritis, Criton. “The Social and Economic Rights Under the Law of the Republic of Cyprus,” in Mélanges Marcel Bridel (Lausanne: 1968).
Tornaritis, Criton. Cyprus and its Constitutional and Other Problems. Nicosia, 1980.
Van de Heyning, Catherine. “No Place Like Home—Discretionary Space for the
Domestic Protection of Fundamental Rights.” In Human Rights Protection in the European Legal Order: The Interaction between the European and the National Courts, edited by Patricia Popelier, C. Van de Heyning, and P. Van Nuffel. 71-78. Cambridge: Intersentia, 2011.
Van Dooren, Machteld Inge. “The European Union and Human Rights: Past, Present, Future.” Merkourios: Utrecht Journal of International and European Law 26, no. 70 (2009).
Vašák, Karel. “A Thirty-Year Struggle: The Sustained Efforts to Give Force of Law to The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” UNESCO Courier 11 (1977).
