Preventing Abusive Constitutionalism in Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev1114Keywords:
abusive constitutionalism, unconstitutional constitutional amendment, basic structuresAbstract
Through Landau’s abusive constitutionalism concept, this article aims to investigate the background behind the plan to conduct further constitutional amendments after over two decades of constitutional amendments in 1999 – 2002. The central question to be addressed is whether it is necessary to pursue further constitutional amendments aimed at restoring the authority of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) to set State Guidelines (PPHN) and extending the President’s term of office from two to three terms. This study utilizes doctrinal-qualitative approaches. It studies relevant laws, regulations, and doctrines to find out the primary factors that contribute to the MPR intention to amend the constitution. This paper argues that while amending a constitution is within the MPR’s constitutional powers, doing so should consider principles of constitutionalism and democracy. A constitutional amendment should be carried for the sake of having a better constitution which uphold constitutionalism –and not the other way around. This paper, therefore, asserts that further constitutional amendment with the above-mentioned agendas potentially lead to abusive constitutionalism if doing so without any clear and legitimate purposes. In the absence of well-defined and reasonable goals, a constitutional amendment may be subjectively used or misused by state institutions to gain more constitutional powers --not to strengthen constitutionalism and democracy. This paper recommends three ways to avoid abusive constitutionalism namely: inserting eternal clause, applying basic doctrine structure, and effectuating civil society.
References
Aryo Wasisto and Prayudi. “Isu Jabatan Presiden Tiga Periode dan Evaluasi Kinerja Eksekutif [Issue of a Three-Term Presidency and Evaluation of Executive Performance].” Pusat Penelitian Badan Keahlian DPR RI report, 13 July 2021.
https://berkas.dpr.go.id/pusaka/files/info_singkat/Info%20Singkat-XIII-13-I-P3DI-Juli-2021-2063.pdf.
Barak, Aharon. “Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments.” Israel Law Review 44, no. 3 (July 2011): 321–41. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021223700018082.
Bhat, Iftikhar Hussian. “Doctrine of Basic Structure as a Constitutional Safeguard in India: Reflection in the Jurisprudence of Other Countries.” International Journal of Research in Humanities and Social Sciences 1, no. 27 (May 2013).
Bulmer, Elliot. What Is a Constitution? Principles and Concepts. 2nd ed. International IDEA Constitution-Building Primer 1. Stockholm: International IDEA, 2017. https://www.idea.int/sites/default/files/publications/what-is-a-constitution-primer.pdf.
Bushnell, David. The Making of Modern Colombia: A Nation in Spite of Itself. 4th print. History/Latin American Studies. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003.
Choudhry, Sujit, Madhav Khosla, and Pratap Bhanu Mehta, eds. The Oxford Handbook of the Indian Constitution. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 2016.
CNN Indonesia. “Wacana Membangkitkan GBHN dan Stabilitas Semu ala Orde Baru [Discourse on Reviving the GBHN (General Guidelines of State Policy) and Pseudo-Stability of the New Order].” 14 August 2019. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190813120238-32-420843/wacana-membangkitkan-gbhn-dan-stabilitas-semu-ala-orde-baru.
Dixon, Rosalind, and Thomas B. Ginsburg. Comparative Constitutional Law in Latin America. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2017.
Dixon, Rosalind, and David E. Landau. Abusive Constitutional Borrowing: Legal Globalization and the Subversion of Liberal Democracy. Oxford Constitutionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021.
Farisa, Fitria Chusna. “Empat Kali Wacana Presiden 3 Periode, Sikap Jokowi Dulu dan Kini [Four Times the Discourse on a Three-Term Presidency, Jokowi’s Stance Then and Now].” Kompas.com, 29 August 2022. https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2022/08/29/10525661/empat-kali-wacana-presiden-3-periode-sikap-jokowi-dulu-dan-kini.
González-Jácome, Jorge. “On Abusive Constitutionalism: Two Critical Impulses.” International Journal of Constitutional Law Blog, 11 June 2015. http://www.iconnectblog.com/2015/06/on-abusive-constitutionalism-two-critical-impulses/.
Hestyarini, Firsty. “Presiden 3 Periode Diusulkan Masuk Amandemen: Jokowi Emang Mau? [Proposal to Include a Three-Term Presidency in an Amendment: Does Jokowi Really Want It?].” RM.id, 22 November 2019. https://rm.id/baca-berita/government-action/22973/presiden-3-periode-diusulkan-masuk-amandemen-jokowi-emang-mau.
Indonesian Rectors Forum. The Formulation of the Convention. Accessed May 14, 2025. http://fri.or.id/rumusan-konvensi.
Kigwiru, Vellah Kedogo. “Comparative Legal Research: A Brief Overview.” Afronomicslaw, January 25, 2020. https://www.afronomicslaw.org/2020/01/24/comparative-legal-research-a-brief-overview.
Landau, David. “Abusive Constitutionalism.” UC Davis Law Review 47, no. 1 (November 2013): 189–260.
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Concerning the Constitutional Court. Jakarta: Government of Indonesia.
Nardi, Dominic J. “Can NGOs Change the Constitution? Civil Society and the Indonesian Constitutional Court.” Contemporary Southeast Asia 40, no. 2 (August 2018): 247–78.
Nart, Irem. “Abusive Constitutionalism in the Heart of Europe: Cases of Hungary and Poland.” Journal of International Relations and Political Science Studies 3, no. 1 (December 2021): 27–44.
Office of the Registrar and the Secretariat General of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia. Foreword to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. Jakarta: Constitutional Court, n.d. Partlett, William. “‘Russia’s Unconstitutional Zeroing Amendment.’” IACL-AIDC
Blog, 16 March 2020. https://blog-iacl-aidc.org/2020-posts/2020/3/16/russias-unconstitutional-zeroing-amendment.
Penetapan Presiden Republik Indonesia Nomor 1 Tahun 1960 tentang Garis-Garis Besar Daripada Haluan Negara [Presidential Stipulation No. 1 of 1960 on the Broad Outlines of State Policy]. Jakarta, 1960.
Pusat Studi Hukum dan Kebijakan. “Stop Gagasan Tiga Periode Masa Jabatan Presiden dan Wakil Presiden: Jangan Buka Keran Otoritarianisme Baru [Stop the Idea of a Three-Term Tenure for President and Vice President: Don’t Open the Door to New Authoritarianism].” Jakarta: PSHK, 2022. https://pshk.or.id/publikasi/stop-gagasan-tiga-periode-masa-jabatan-presiden-dan-wakil-presiden-jangan-buka-keran-otoritarianisme-baru/.
Raza, Aqa. “The Doctrine of ‘Basic Structure’ of the Indian Constitution: A Critique.” SSRN Scholarly Paper, 12 July 2015. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2661127.
Rozna'i, Yaniv. Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments: The Limits of Amendment Powers. Oxford Constitutional Theory. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 2019.
Şirin, Tolga. “How Many Times Can Erdoğan Be a Presidential Candidate?” International Journal of Constitutional Law Blog, 3 August 2021. http://www.iconnectblog.com/2021/08/how-many-times-can-erdogan-be-a-presidential-candidate/.
Szalma Fatimarahma. “Usulan Jokowi 3 Periode Kembali Muncul, Ini Penggagasnya! [Proposal for Jokowi’s Third Term Reemerges, Here’s the Proposer!].” Kabar24, 1 July 2022. https://kabar24.bisnis.com/read/20220701/15/1549844/usulan-jokowi-3-periode-kembali-muncul-ini-penggagasnya.
Tap MPRS No. IV/MPRS/1963 tentang Pedoman Pelaksanaan Garis-Garis Besar Haluan Negara dan Haluan Pembangunan [MPR Decree No. IV/MPRS/1963 on Guidelines for Implementation of the Broad Outlines of State Policy and Development Guidelines]. Jakarta, 1963.
Tempo.co. “Pengamat Politik Qodari Jelaskan Alasan Mendukung Wacana Jokowi 3 Periode [Political Observer Qodari Explains Reasons for Supporting the Jokowi Three-Term Discourse].” Tempo.co, 16 March 2021. https://www.tempo.co/politik/pengamat-politik-qodari-jelaskan-alasan-mendukung-wacana-jokowi-3-periode-530695.
The Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. The Fundamental Law of Hungary.
Tilik Data. “Presiden Tiga Periode [Three-Term Presidency].” LAB45, 22 June 2021.
https://www.lab45.id/detail/95/presiden-tiga-periode.
Versteeg, Mila, Timothy Horley, Anne Meng, Mauricio Guim, and Marilyn Guirguis. “The Law and Politics of Presidential Term Limit Evasion.” Columbia Law Review 120, no. 1 (January 2020): 173–248.
William Partlett. “‘Russia’s Unconstitutional Zeroing Amendment.’” IACL-AIDC Blog, 16 March 2020. https://blog-iacl-aidc.org/2020-posts/2020/3/16/russias-unconstitutional-zeroing-amendment.
