Beyond Resolution 2347 (2017): The Search for Protection of Cultural Heritage from Armed Non-State Groups

Giulia Baj

doi:10.31078/consrev716

Beyond Resolution 2347 (2017): The Search for Protection of Cultural Heritage from Armed Non-State Groups

Giulia Baj

Abstract

One expression of cultural rights is the right to enjoy cultural heritage. However, the latter is not efficiently protected in situations of armed conflict. In many cases, armed non-State groups (ANSGs) have destroyed or looted cultural heritage items. The United Nations Security Council has intervened with Resolution 2347 (2017), welcomed by many as a milestone in the international protection of cultural heritage in conflict situations. However, this Resolution presents several limitations. The protection of cultural heritage from destruction and exploitation does not appear as the main focus, but rather as a means to fight terrorist groups. The attacks against cultural heritage are considered “war crimes”, but only “under certain circumstances”. The Resolution encourages States “that have not yet done so to consider ratifying” treaties on the issue in question; however, these instruments are treaties drafted and ratified by States. Problems of compliance by non-State actors, as ANSGs, arise. Hence, the capacity of theResolution to effectively protect cultural heritage in conflicts involving ANSGs is debated. This paper analyses the text of Resolution 2347 (2017), resorting to traditional means of interpretation to highlight its limitations, and considers how a general sense of the necessity to protect cultural heritage from attacks committed by ANSGs has emerged, as demonstrated by the International Criminal Court's Al Mahdi case. The paper then considers other ways to guarantee the protection of cultural heritage from ANSGs. A proposal for stronger protection of cultural heritage by States through both international humanitarian law (IHL) and international human rights law (IHRL) is presented. In particular, the connection between the protection of cultural heritage, the guarantee of cultural rights and other human rights is presented, resorting to instruments of doctrine and analyzing instruments of practice. Finally, the case for the stronger international cooperation for the protection of cultural heritage is made; problems of compliance by ANSGs may persist, but the systematic destruction of cultural heritage items can be considered a violation of cultural rights, thus requiring the cooperation of all international stakeholders.

Keywords

Cultural Heritage, Cultural Rights, International Human Rights Law, International Humanitarian Law

Full Text:

PDF

References

Amoroso, Alessandro Mario et al. “The War Report: Armed Conflicts in 2018.” A Paper, Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights, 2019.

Bellal, Annyssa. “What Are ‘Armed Non-State Actors’? A Legal and Semantic Approach.” In International Humanitarian Law and Non-State Actors, edited by Ezequiel Heffes, Marcos D. Kotlik, and Manuel J. Ventura, 21–46. The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-339- 9_2.

Busé, Margaret S. “Non-State Actors and Their Significance.” Journal of Conventional Weapons Destruction 5, no. 3 (2001).

“Charter of the United Nations”. Opened for signature June 26, 1945. https:// treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/No%20Volume/Part/un_charter.pdf.

Ciampi, Carlo Azeglio. Intervento del Presidente della Repubblica Carlo Azeglio Ciampi in occasione della consegna delle medaglie d’oro ai benemeriti della cultura e dell’arte [Speech of the President of the Italian Republic Carlo Azeglio Ciampi for the delivery of the Gold Medals for Culture and Arts merits], May 5, 2003.

Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. “General Comment No. 21 Right of Everyone to Take Part in Cultural Life (Art. 15, Para. 1 (a), of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights).” United Nations Economic and Social Council, December 21, 2009.

Constantinides, Aristotle. “Human Rights Obligations and Accountability of Armed Opposition Groups: The Practice of the Un Security Council.” Human Rights & International Legal Discourse 4, no. 1 (2010).

“Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict.” Opened for signature May 14, 1954. United Nations Treaty Series no. 249, 215, https://treaties.un.org/Pages/showDetails. aspx?objid=0800000280145bac.

“Convention (I) for the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded and Sick in Armed Forces in the Field, Geneva, 12 August 1949, Commentary of 2016. Article 3: Conflicts not of an international character. Accessed August 22, 2020. https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/Comment.xsp?acti on=openDocument&documentId=59F6CDFA490736C1C1257F7D004BA0EC.

Corte Costituzionale Italiana [Italian Constitutional Court]. Sent. 151/86 A. Giudizio di legittimità costituzionale in via principale [Judgment on question of constitutionality], No. 151/1986 (June 27, 1986).

Corte Costituzionale Italiana [Italian Constitutional Court]. Sent. 194/2013 Giudizio di legittimità costituzionale in via principale [Judgment on question of constitutionality] No. 194/2013 (July 17, 2013).

Corte Costituzionale Italiana [Italian Constitutional Court]. Sent. 232/2005. Giudizio di legittimità costituzionale in via principale [Judgment on question of constitutionality], No. 232/2005 (June 16, 2005).

Evans, Graham, and Jeffrey Newnham. The Penguin Dictionary of International Relations. New York: Penguin Group USA, 1998.

Fleck, Dieter. The Handbook of International Humanitarian Law. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2013.

Fortin, Katharine. “The Law on Belligerency and Insurgency, and International Legal Personality.” In The Accountability of Armed Groups under Human Rights Law, edited by Katharine Fortin. Oxford: Oxford University Press,

Accessed September 21, 2020. https://oxford.universitypressscholarship. com/view/10.1093/oso/9780198808381.001.0001/oso-9780198808381-chapter-4.

Francioni, Francesco. “Beyond State Sovereignty: The Protection of Cultural Heritage as a Shared Interest of Humanity.” Michigan Journal of International Law 25, no. 4 (2004).

Gaub, Florence. “State Vacuums and Non-State Actors in the Middle East and North Africa.” In The Frailty of Authority Borders, Non-State Actors and Power Vacuums in a Changing Middle East, edited by Lorenzo Kamel. Roma: Edizioni Nuova cultura, 2017.

“Geneva Convention for the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded and Sick in Armed Forces in the Field.” Opened for signature August 12, 1949. United Nations Treaty Series no. 75. https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl. nsf/7c4d08d9b287a42141256739003e636b/fe20c3d903ce27e3c125641e004a92f3

Gerstenblith, Patty. “Beyond the 1954 Hague Convention.” In Cultural Awareness in the Military: Developments and Implications for Future Humanitarian Cooperation, edited by Robert Albro and Bill Ivey, 83–99. Springer, 2014.

Hall, Macer. “Boris Johnson Urges Brits to Vote Brexit to ‘Take Back Control'." Daily Express, June 20, 2016. https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/681706/ Boris-Johnson-vote-Brexit-take-back-control.

Hannum, Hurst. “The UDHR in National and International Law.” Health and Human Rights 3, no. 2 (1998). https://doi.org/10.2307/4065305.

Hausler, Kristin. “Cultural Heritage and the Security Council: Why Resolution 2347 Matters.” QIL–Question of International Law. QIL, Zoom-In 48 (2018).

Heintze, Hans-Joachim. “On the Relationship between Human Rights Law Protection and International Humanitarian Law.” International Review Red Cross 86 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1017/S156077550018040X.

Henckaerts, Jean-Marie. “The Protection of Cultural Property in Non-International Armed Conflicts.” In Protecting Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, edited

by Nout van Woudenberg and Liesbeth Lijnzaad. International Humanitarian Law Series, v. 29. Leiden; Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2010.

Institut de Droit International. "The Application of International Humanitarian Law and Fundamental Human Rights, in Armed Conflicts in which Non- State Entities are Parties." The Institute of International Law, 1999.

International Committee of the Red Cross. “Geneva Conventions on the Law of War,” August 12, 1949. 75 No. 973. United Nations Treaty Series.

International Committee of the Red Cross. “Rule 38. Attacks Against Cultural Property.” IHL Database. Customary IHL (blog). Accessed October 23, 2020. https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docs/v1_rul_rule38.

“International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.” Opened for signature December 16, 1966. United Nations Treaty Series no. 993, 3. https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%20993/volume-993- I-14531-English.pdf.

International Court of Justice. “Advisory Opinion on Legality of the threat or use of nuclear weapons.” International Court of Justice Reports, 1996, 226.

International Criminal Court. “Summary of the Judgment and Sentence in the Case of The Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi,” 2016.

International Criminal Court Trial Chamber, Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi Case No. ICC-01/12-01/15 (International Criminal Court 2016).

International Law Association. “Johannesburg Conference on Non State Actors.” International Law Association Reports of Conferences, 2016.

INTERPOL. “Protecting Cultural Heritage through Interagency Cooperation. WIESBADEN, Germany – International Experts on the Illicit Trade of Cultural Property Have Met to Boost Interagency Cooperation Both at the National and International Level.” September 23, 2019. https://www.interpol. int/News-and-Events/News/2019/Protecting-cultural-heritage-through- interagency-cooperation.

INTERPOL. “The Issues - Cultural Property.” Accessed October 20, 2020. https://www.interpol.int/Crimes/Cultural-heritage-crime/The-issues-cultural- property.

Jackson, Ashley. “In Their Words: Perceptions of Armed Non-State Actors on Humanitarian Action.” Geneva: Geneva Call, May 2016. https:// www.genevacall.org/wp-content/uploads/dlm_uploads/2016/09/WHS_ Report_2016_web.pdf.

Jakubowski, Andrzej. “Resolution 2347: Mainstreaming the Protection of Cultural Heritage at the Global Level.” Questions of International Law 48 (2018).

Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970), Advisory Opinion (International Court of Justice June 21, 1971).

McQuinn, Brian, and Fabio Oliva. “Preliminary Scoping Report - Analyzing and Engaging Non-State Armed Groups in the Field.” United Nations System Staff College, n.d.

Ocampo, Satur. “Duterte’s Odd Defense of Philippine Sovereignty.” Bulatlat, April 22, 2018. https://www.bulatlat.com/2018/04/22/dutertes-odd-defense- philippine-sovereignty.

Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. “Fact Sheet No. 33.” Geneva, 2008. https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/ FactSheet33en.pdf.

Papastavridis, Efthymios. “Interpretation of Security Council Resolutions under Chapter VII in the Aftermath of the Iraqi Crisis.” International and Comparative Law Quarterly 56, no. 1 (January 2007): 83–118. https://doi. org/10.1093/iclq/lei151.

Pavia, Will. “Amazon Rainforest Belongs to Brasil Not Mankind, Bolsonaro Tells UN.” The Times, September 25, 2019. https://www.thetimes.co.uk/ article/amazon-rainforest-belongs-to-brazil-not-mankind-bolsonaro-tells- un-2j2f55l2j.

Pearlman, Wendy, and Kathleen Gallagher Cunningham. “Non-state Actors, Fragmentation, and Conflict Processes.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 56, no. 1 (February 2012). https://doi.org/10.1177/0022002711429669.

Posner, Eric A. “The International Protection of Cultural Property: Some Skeptical Observations.” Chicago Journal of International Law 8, no. 1 (n.d.).

“Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 and Relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts (Protocol II)”. Opened for signature June 8, 1977. United Nations Treaty Series, vol. 1125. https://treaties.un.org/doc/publication/unts/volume%201125/volume- 1125-i-17513-english.pdf.

Republic of Italy. “Cultural Heritage and Landscape Code of the Italian Republic of January 22, 2004, D. Lgs. 42/2004”. https://www.camera.it/parlam/leggi/ deleghe/testi/04042dl.htm.

“Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.” Opened for signature July 17, 1998. United Nations Treaty Series, vol. 2187, No. 38544.

Republic of Italy. “Constitution of the Republic of Italy – 1948.” https://www. senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/costituzione.pdf.

Richardson, Paul B. “Sovereignty, the Hyperreal, and ‘Taking Back Control.’” Annals of the American Association of Geographers 109, no. 6 (November 2, 2019). https://doi.org/10.1080/24694452.2019.1587283.

Schneckener, Ulrich. “Spoilers or Governance Actors?: Engaging Armed Non- State Groups in Areas of Limited Statehood.” SFB Governance working paper series, 21, 2009. https://www.sfb-governance.de/publikationen/sfb- 700-working_papers/wp21/index.html.

“Second Protocol the Hague Convention of 1954 for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict.” Opened for signature March 26, 1999. United Nations Treaty Series no. 2253, 172. https://treaties.un.org/ Pages/showDetails.aspx?objid=0800000280076dd2.

Shultz, Richard H., Douglas Farah, and Itamara V. Lochard. “Armed Groups: A Tier-One Security Priority.” INSS Occasional Paper. USAF Institute for National Security Studies, 2004.

Steiner, Henry J., Philip Alston, and Ryan Goodman. International Human Rights in Context. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.

UNESCO. “Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage.” Opened for signature October 17, 2003. United Nations Treaty Series no. 2368, 3. https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%202368/v2368.pdf.

UNESCO. “Declaration concerning the Intentional Destruction of Cultural Heritage.” September 29, 2003. Records of the General Conference, 32nd session no. 1, 187, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000133171.page=68.

United Nations Human Rights Council, 25th session. “Promotion of the enjoyment of the cultural rights of everyone and respect for cultural diversity.” April 15, 2004, U.N. Doc. A/HRC/RES/25/19, https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/ doc/UNDOC/GEN/G14/136/10/PDF/G1413610.pdf?OpenElement.

United Nations Human Rights Council, 34th session. “Report of the Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights.” January 16, 2017, U.N. Doc. A/ HRC/34/56, https://undocs.org/en/A/HRC/34/56.

United Nations Human Rights Council, 9th session. Res. 9/9, “Protection of the human rights of civilians in armed conflict." September 18, 2008. U.N. Doc. A/HRC/RES/9/9.

United Nations Security Council, “7907th meeting,”, S/PV.7907, March 24, 2017. https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C- 8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/s_pv_7907.pdf.

United Nations Security Council. “Final report of the United Nations Commission of Experts established pursuant to security council resolution 780 (1992). Annex XI: destruction of cultural property report.” U.N. Doc. S/1994/674/ Add.2 (December 28, 1994).

United Nations Security Council. Res 2331, U.N. Doc. S/RES/2331 (December 20, 2016).

United Nations Security Council. Res 2340, U.N. Doc. S/RES/2340 (February 8, 2017).

United Nations Security Council. Res 2349, U.N. Doc. S/RES/2349 (March 31, 2017).

United Nations Security Council. Res. 2347, U.N. Doc. S/RES/2347 (March 24, 2017).

“Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties”. Opened for signature May 23, 1969. United Nations Treaty Series no. 1155, https://treaties.un.org/doc/ Treaties/1980/01/19800127%2000-52%20AM/Ch_XXIII_01.pdf.

Wood, Michael C. “Interpretation of Security Council Resolutions.” Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 2 (1998).

World Conference on Human Rights. “Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action.” June 25, 1993, https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/ ProfessionalInterest/vienna.pdf.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev716