Against the Odds: Protection of Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine

Yurii Sheliazhenko

doi:10.31078/consrev613

Against the Odds: Protection of Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine

Yurii Sheliazhenko

Abstract

The article traces historical development, doctrine, and impact of constitutional review in Ukraine related to matters of social justice. It is shown that international review of Ukraine’s reports on observance of human rights obligations indicated a low level of compliance during the absence of independent constitutional review by the judiciary. After the establishment of the constitutional review, the compliance was improved against all doubts, whether socio-economic rights are justiciable in the Ukrainian context, and whether the judges are empowered enough to reshape authoritarian policies. Constitutional Court of Ukraine developed a doctrine of social justice based on the values of the rule of law, liberty, and equality, founding a pragmatic balance between the imperatives of individual freedom and economic security. In legal reasoning, judges implemented ideas of the human-centered state and personal autonomy in civil society, close to liberal democratic views, expressed by framers of the Constitution of Ukraine.

Keywords

Constitutional Court of Ukraine; Democratic Nation-building; Economic Security; Human Rights; Personal Autonomy; Social Justice

Full Text:

PDF

References

Bantekas, Ilias, and Cephas Lumina, eds. Sovereign Debt and Human Rights. Oxford University Press, 2019.

Baulin, Yurii. “The Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on the Protection of Human Rights Recognized by the Ukrainian Legislation and Acts of International Law.” In Global Constitutionalism and Multi-layered Protection of Human Rights – Exploring the Possibility of Establishing a Regional Human Rights Mechanism in Asia, 133–67. Seoul: Constitutional Court of Korea, 2016.

BBC Ukraine. “Minfin shukatyme shakhraiv sered tykh, komu platiat dopomohu, [Ministry of Finances seeks for fraudsters among recipients of social benefits].” 1 March 2016. https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/business/2016/03/160301_verification_social_benefits_az

Bohoslavsky, Juan Pablo, and Jernej Letnar Cernic, eds. Making Sovereign Financing and Human Rights Work. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2016.

Budz, Iryna. “What Prevents Ukrainian Judiciary From Becoming Truly Effective And Independent?” VoxUkraine, last modified on 24 July 2019. https://voxukraine.org/en/what-prevents-ukrainian-judiciary-from-becoming-trulyeffective-and-independent/.

Bulkat, Liudmyla. “Pytannia sotsialnoho zakhystu v aktakh Konstytutsiinoho Sudu Ukrainy [The issue of social protection in the acts of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine.]” University Scientific Notes 58 (2016): 23–34.

Chinkin, Christine. “The Protection of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Post-Conflict.” Paper series commissioned by the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (2009). http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/women/docs/Paper_Protection_ESCR.pdf.

Chubar, Liudmyla. “Problemy realizatsii sotsialnykh prav na suchasnomu etapi ta yikh zakhyst u konstytutsiinomu sudochynstvi [Contemporary problems of realization of social rights and its defense in constitutional justice.]” The Herald of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine 6 (2003):111–4.

Coalition for Personal Autonomy. “Ukraine: problems with implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.”

Pravdoshukach, 31 August 2018. https://truth.in.ua/en/public/358/.

Conclusion of 26 October 1990 in the case No 11(2-1) concerning legislation on propiska of citizens, Committee of Constitutional Supervision of the USSR.

Constitution (The Basic Law) of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic of 1937.

Constitution (The Basic Law) of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic of 1978.

Constitution of Ukraine, adopted 28 June 1996.

Constitutional Court of Ukraine. “Konstytutsiina yustytsiia ta rynkova ekonomika:

suchasni ta perspektyvni naukovo-praktychni realii [Constitutional Justice and Market Economy: Contemporary Scientific and Practical Trends and Prospects].” Accessed on 15 November 2019. http://www.ccu.gov.ua/novyna/konstytuciyna-yustyciya-ta-rynkova-ekonomika-suchasni-ta-perspektyvninaukovo-praktychni.

Constitutional Court of Ukraine. “The Acts of CCU.” Accessed on 15 November 2019. http://ccu.gov.ua/en/storinka/acts-ccu.

Council of Europe. Enhancing the National Legal Framework in Ukraine for Protecting the Human Rights of Internally Displaced Persons. Kyiv: 2016.

Council of Europe, Venice Commission. “Meeting on the draft Constitution of Ukraine: Secretariat memorandum, CDL(1993)042-e.” 25 June 1993.

Council of Europe, Venice Commission. “Opinion on the Constitution of Ukraine, CDL-INF(1997)002-e.” 11 March 1997.

Council of Europe, Venice Commission. “Opinion on the draft Constitution of Ukraine, CDL-INF(1996)006-e.” 21 May 1996.

Council of Europe, Venice Commission. “Opinion on the present constitutional situation in Ukraine following the adoption of the Constitutional Agreement between the Supreme Rada of Ukraine and the president of Ukraine, CDL(1995)040-e.” 11 September 1995.

Council of Europe, Venice Commission. “The CODICES database.” Accessed on 15 November 2019. http://www.codices.coe.int.

Courtis, Christian. Courts and the Legal Enforcement of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Comparative Experiences of Justiciability. Geneva: International Commission of Jurists, 2008.

Decision in case No 15-rp/1998 of 25 November 1998, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 2-rp/99 of 2 March 1999, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 2-rp/2000 of 10 February 2000, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 11-rp/2000 of 18 October 2000, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 18-rp/2001 of 13 December 2001, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 6-rp/2002 of 26 March 2002, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 10-rp/2002 of 29 May 2002, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 11-rp/2002 of 13 June 2002, Constitutional Court of Ukraine(Ukraine).

Decision in case No 18-rp/2002 of 21 November 2002, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 14-rp/2004 of 7 July 2004, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 15-rp/2004 of 2 November 2004, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 6-rp/2007 of 9 July 2007, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 15-rp/2010 of 10 June 2010, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 20-rp/2011 of 26 December 2011, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 2-rp/2012 of 20 January 2012, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 3-rp/2012 of 25 January 2012, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 12-rp/2013 of 28 November 2013, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 6-rp/2014 of 11 June 2014, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 4-rp/2016 of 8 June 2016, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 6-rp/2016 of 8 September 2016, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 6-r/2018 of 17 June 2018, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 7-r/2018 of 11 October 2018, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 8-r/2018 of 11 October 2018, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 9-r/2018 of 7 November 2018, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Decision in case No 2-r(ІІ)/2019 of 15 May 2019, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Elkins, Zachary, et al. The Endurance of National Constitutions. Cambridge University Press, 2009.

Faiz, Pan Mohamad. “A Prospect and Challenges for Adopting Constitutional Complaint and Constitutional Question in the Indonesian Constitutional Court.” Constitutional Review 2, no. 1 (2016): 103–28. http://dx.doi.org/10.31078/consrev215.

Gregory, Paul R., and Irwin L. Collier Jr. “Unemployment in the Soviet Union: Evidence from the Soviet Interview Project.” The American Economic Review 78, no. 4 (1988): 613-32.

H46-35 Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov, Zhovner group and Burmych and Others v. Ukraine: Supervision of the execution of the European Court’s judgments, CM/Del/Dec(2019)1348/H46-35 (Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers, 6 June 2019).

Hausmaninger, Herbert. “The Committee of Constitutional Supervision of the USSR.” Cornell International Law Journal 23, no. 2 (1990): 287–322.

Holovaty, Serhiy. “Concept of the Rule of Law – Difficulties of its perception in the post-Soviet legal culture (Ukraine’s experience).” Report, Venice Commission, 2016. Accessed on 15 November 2019, https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-JU(2016)015-e.

Holovin, Anatolii. “15 Years of Constitutional Justice in Ukraine: Accomplishments, Challenges, Prospects.” In The Protection of Human Rights by Bodies Of Constitutional Justice: Possibilities And Problems of Individual Access. Materials of International Conference, 411–24. Kyiv: Logos, 2011.

Hultai, Mykhailo. “Normative constitutional complaint in Ukraine as a national legal remedy.” Report, Venice Commission, 2018, accessed on 15 November 2019, https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-JU(2018)015-e.

Iarskaia-Smirnova, Elena, and Karen Lyons. “Social Work in Former Soviet Union Countries: Mapping the Progress of ‘The Professional Project’.” European Journal of Social Work 21, no. 1 (2018): 114–27. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691 457.2016.1255926.

Inshyn, Mykola, Yurii Міroshnychenko, and Yurii Paida. “Protection Of Constitutional Cultural Rights and Freedoms of Citizens by The Constitutional Court of Ukraine.” Baltic Journal of Economic Studies 4, no. 4 (2018): 134–9. https://doi.org/10.30525/2256-0742/2018-4-4-134-139.

International Commission of Jurists. “Ukraine: dismissal and criminal prosecution of judges undermine independence of the judiciary.” Last modified on 20 March 2014, https://www.icj.org/ukraine-dismissal-and-criminal-prosecutionof-judges-undermine-independence-of-the-judiciary/.

International Monetary Fund. “Ukraine — Letter of Intent, Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies and Technical Memorandum of Understanding.” 11 March 2004, https://www.imf.org/external/np/loi/2004/ukr/01/index.htm.

International Monetary Fund. “Ukraine Letter of Intent and Memorandum of Economic Policies.” 16 March 1999, https://www.imf.org/external/np/loi/1999/031799.htm.

International Monetary Fund. “Ukraine: Letter of Intent, and Technical Memorandum of Understanding.” 10 December 2010, https://www.imf.org/external/np/loi/2010/ukr/121010.pdf.

International Monetary Fund. “Ukraine: Letter of Intent, Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies, and Technical Memorandum of Understanding.” 27 February 2015, https://www.imf.org/external/np/loi/2015/ukr/022715.pdf.

Judgment of 12 October 2017 in the case of Burmych and Others v. Ukraine, European Court of Human Rights.

Kopieichykov, Volodymyr. Narodovlastie i lichnost’ [Democracy and Personality]. Kyiv: Ukraina, 1991.

Landau, David. “The Reality of Social Rights Enforcement.” Harvard International Law Journal 53, no. 1 (Winter 2012): 189–247.

Law of Ukraine on Amendments to the Law of Ukraine about the State Budget of 2018 year.

Law of Ukraine on the State Budget of 2019.

LB.ua. “Yanukovych charged with constitutional coup. Ex-Justice Minister Lavrynovych is another suspect in the case.” last modified on 6 September 2017, https://en.lb.ua/news/2017/09/06/4436_yanukovych_charged.html.

Michalowski, Sabine. “Sovereign Debt and Social Rights – Legal Reflections on a Difficult Relationship.” Human Rights Law Review 8, no. 1 (2008): 35–68. https://doi.org/10.1093/hrlr/ngm042.

Ministry of Social Policy of Ukraine. “Vnutrishnio peremishcheni osoby [Internally displaced persons].” Accessed 15 November 2019, https://www.msp.gov.ua/timeline/Vnutrishno-peremishcheni-osobi.html.

Odling-Smee, John, et al. Ukraine: IMF Economic Reviews. Washington: International Monetary Fund, 1995.

Opinion in case No 2-v/1999 of 2 June 1999, Constitutional Court of Ukraine (Ukraine).

Popova, Maria. “Ukraine’s Politicized Courts.” In Beyond the Euromaidan: Comparative Perspectives on Advancing Reform in Ukraine, edited by Henry E. Hale and Robert W. Orttung, 143–61. Stanford University Press, 2016.

Reply from the authorities (22/08/2019) following a communication from a NGO (25/07/2019) in the cases of Burmych and Others, Ivanov and Zhovner group v. Ukraine, Applications No. 46852/13, 40450/04, 56848/00 (Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers, 23 August 2019).

Ricón, José Luis. “The Soviet Union: Achieving full employment.” Nintil, accessed on 15 November 2019, https://nintil.com/the-soviet-union-achieving-fullemployment/.

Roosevelt, Eleanor. “Human Rights.” In Peace on Earth, 65–71. New York: Hermitage House, 1949.

Sheliazhenko, Yurii. “Autonomous Processual Model of Law.” Philosophy of Law and General Theory of Law 1 (2019): 91–111. https://doi.org/10.21564/2227-7153.2019.1.186739.

Ssenyonjo, Manisuli. Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in International Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2009.

Strydom, Hennie. “The Protection of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in International Law.” Constitutional Review 5, no. 2 (2019): 222–247. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev522.

Swaminathan, Rajesh. “Regulating Development: Structural Adjustment and the Case for National Enforcement of Economic and Social Rights.” Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 37, no. 1 (1998):161.

Trochev, Alexei. “Fragmentation? Defection? Legitimacy? Explaining Judicial Roles in Post-Communist Colored Revolutions.” In Consequential Courts: Judicial Roles in Global Perspective, edited by Diana Kapiszewski, Gordon Silverstein, and Robert A. Kagan, 67–92. Cambridge University Press, 2013.

Tymchenko, Ivan. “Mechanism of Constitutional Jurisdiction in Defence of Rights and Freedoms of Man and Citizen.” In The Legal System of Ukraine: Past, Present, and Future. Volume II. Constitutional Foundations of the Legal System of Ukraine and Problems of Improvement, edited by Yurii Bytiak et al., 121–47. Kharkiv: Pravo, 2013.

UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Handbook for National Human Rights Institutions. New York and Geneva: United Nations, 2005.

UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Transitional Justice and Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Geneva: United Nations, 2014.

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “An Evaluation of the Obligation to Take Steps to the Maximum of Available Resources Under an Optional Protocol to the Covenant: Statement of the Committee On Economic, Social And Cultural Rights.” E/C.12/2007/1, 21 September 2007.

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Twenty-sixth (extraordinary) session: summary record of the 41st meeting.” E/C.12/2001/SR.41 (28 August 2001).

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Second periodic reports submitted by States parties to the Covenant concerning rights covered by articles 6 to 9 in accordance with the first stage of the programme established by the Economic and Social Council in its resolution 1988 (LX): Ukranian Soviet Socialist Republic.” E/1984/7/Add.9, 13 March 1984.

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Reports submitted in accordance with Council resolution 1988 (LX) by states parties to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights covered by articles 6 to 9: Ukranian Soviet Socialist Republic.” E/1978/8/Add.22, 26 September 1978.

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Sessional working group on the implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural rights: summary record of the 18th meeting.” E/1980/WG.l/SR.18, 28 April 1980. United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Sessional working group of

governmental experts on the implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural rights: summary record of the 15th meeting.” E/1984/WG.1/SR.15, 30 April 1984.

United Nations, Economic and Social Council. “Ukraine: Implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Third periodic reports submitted by States parties under articles 16 and 17 of the Covenant.” E/1994/104/Add.4, 17 October 1994.

United Nations, Human Rights Council. “Report of the Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights, Farida Shaheed: Copyright policy and the right to science and culture.” A/HRC/28/57, 24 December 2014.

United Nations, Human Rights Council. “Summary of Stakeholders’ submissions on Ukraine: Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.” A/HRC/WG.6/28/UKR/3, 31 August 2017.

United Nations. “Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action.” World Conference on Human Rights, A/CONF.157/23, 12 July 1993.

Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. “Proclamation of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Concerning the Cancellation by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of the Law of Ukraine on the Temporary Prohibition of Rising the Prices and Tariffs for Housing, Municipal Services, and Public Transport Provided to Citizens of Ukraine.” 16 March 1999. Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. “Legislation of Ukraine.” accessed on 15 November 2019, https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws?lang=en.

Verlanov, Serhii. Ekonomichni i sotsialni prava liudyny: yevropeiski standarty ta yikh vprovadzhennia v yurydychnu praktyku Ukrainy (zahalnoteoretychne doslidzhennia) [Economic and social rights of human: European standards and their implementation in judicial practice in Ukraine (broad theoretical research)]. Lviv: Krai, 2009.

Winesjuly, Michael. “Zimbabwe Price Controls Cause Chaos.” New York Times, 3 July 2007, https://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/03/world/africa/03cndwzimbabwe.html.

Wolczuk, Kataryna. The Moulding of Ukraine: The Constitutional Politics of State Formation. Budapest: Central European University Press, 2001.

World Bank Data. “Inflation, consumer prices (annual %) – Ukraine, World(1997-2001).”Accessed on 15 November 2019. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FP.CPI.TOTL.ZG?end=2001&locations=UA-1W&start=1997.

Yuzkov, Leonid, and Yevheniia Tykhonova. “Konstytutsiia yurydychna i faktychna [Juridical and factual constitution].” Law of Ukraine 1 (1992): 9. Yuzkov, Leonid. Constitution of Soviet Ukraine. Kyiv: Politvidav Ukraini Publishers, 1984.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev613