Comity or Confrontation: Budgeting Independence of the American Judiciary

Justin Apperson

Abstract


While many American court systems have constitutional funding protections judicial salaries, the judiciary in the position of bargaining for funding for staff, services, technology, facilities, supplies, and other goods to adequately fund the constitutional mission of adjudication. Courts have looked to two principal strategies in securing funding. First, courts have tried to improve the relationship with the other branches through long-term connections and demonstrations of sound judicial governance. Courts have sought to improve their strategic planning, incorporating novel uses of data including performance measures, with the collateral hope of enhancing budget justifications. Courts have also tested political strategies for self-advocacy, including elevating judicial officers as spokespersons for the judicial branch, mobilizing stakeholders, and lobbying key officials. Second, courts have invoked the inherent powers of the judiciary as a separate and co-equal branch to compel funding that is reasonably necessary to administration of justice. Judicial leaders have typically disfavored this technique, which presents its own risks of trespassing on legislative power and impairing longer-term strategies for building bridges and understanding between the branches, except in patterns of legislative neglect or hostility towards judicial independence.

Keywords


Judicial Independence; Budgeting; Communications Strategies; Inherent Powers

Full Text:

PDF

References


Administrative Office of the United States Courts. “The Judiciary Fiscal Year

Congressional Budget Summary.” 2023. https://www.uscourts.gov/about-

federal-courts/governance-judicial-conference/congressional-budget-request.

Administrative Office of the United States Courts. “Understanding the Federal

Courts.” Washington, AOUSC. https://www.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/

understanding-federal-courts.pdf.

American Bar Association. “Federal Court Funding.” Last Modified June 1, 2023.

https://www.americanbar.org/advocacy/governmental_legislative_work/

priorities_policy/independence_of_the_judiciary/federal-court-funding/.

American Bar Association. “Justice in Jeopardy: Report of the American Bar

Association Commission on the 21st Century Judiciary.” 2003. Web, https://

www.opensocietyfoundations.org/publications/justice-jeopardy-report-

american-bar-assocation-commission-21st-century-judiciary.

American Bar Association. “Report to the House of Delegates: Task Force on

Preservation of the Justice System.” 2011.

American Civil Liberties Union v. Dunleavy, No. 3AN-19-08349CI (3d D. Alaska

https://drive.google.com/file/d/11G2bt-Rm795Tc7nQAEUCemttEZ23fjiJ/

view.

Anderson, James M and Eric Helland. “How Much Should Judges Be Paid? An

Empirical Study on the Effect of Judicial Pay on the State Bench.” Stanford

Law Review 64, no. 5 (May 2012).

Anderson, Jonas. “Judicial Lobbying.” Washington Law Review 91, no. 2 (June

.

Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009).

Balassone, Merrill. “The Trial Court Funding Formula, Explained.” Judicial Branch

of California. Published July 27, 2017. https://newsroom.courts.ca.gov/news/

trial-court-funding-formula-explained.

Brennan Center for Justice. “Fairchild v. Kansas.” Published December 18, 2015.

https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/court-cases/fairchild-v-kansas.

Caplan, Lincoln. “The Political War Against the Kansas Supreme Court.” The

New Yorker, February 5, 2016. https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/

the-political-war-against-the-kansas-supreme-court.

Chappell, Bill. “W.Va Supreme Court Justice Allen Loughry is Charged with

Counts, Including Fraud.” NPR. June 20, 2018. https://www.npr.

org/2018/06/20/621836487/w-va-supreme-court-justice-allen-loughry-is-

charged-with-22-counts-including-fraud.

Congressional Research Service. “Introduction to the Federal Budget Process.”

Updated January 10, 2023. https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/

R46240.

Congressional Research Service. “Judiciary Budget Request FY 2023.” Updated

April 25, 2022, https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11842.

Cournoyer, Caroline. “Measuring the Efficiency of Courts.” Governing. Published

July 26, 2011. https://www.governing.com/archive/measuring-the-efficiency-

of-courts.html#:~:text=CourTools%20are%20largely%20efficiency%20

and,been%20pending%20before%20the%20court.

Court Statistics Project. “Federal and State Caseload Trends: 2012-2021.” National

Center for State Courts, accessed September 25, 2023, https://www.

courtstatistics.org/court-statistics/state-versus-federal-caseloads.

Douglas, James and Roger Hartley. “Budgeting for State Courts: The Perceptions

of Key Officials regarding Determinants of Budget Success.” The Justice

System Journal 24, no. 3 (2003).

Douglas, James and Roger Hartley. “Making the Case for Court Funding: The

Important Role of Lobbying,” Judges’ Journal (Summer 2004): 35.

Douglas, James and Roger Hartley. “State Court Strategies and Politics during the

Appropriations Process.” Public Budgeting and Finance 21 (Spring 2001): 42-43.

Eckholm. Erik. “Outraged by Kansas Justices’ Rulings, Republicans Seek to

Reshape the Court.” New York Times. April 2, 2016.

Edmondson, Catie. “How to Enforce a Debt Deal: Through ‘Meat-Ax’ Cuts Nobody

Wants.” New York Times, June 1, 2023.

David Engstrom. “The Twiqbal Puzzle and Empirical Study of Civil Procedure.”

Stanford Law Review 65, no. 6 (July 2013).

Federal Judicial Center. “The Executive Role in Judicial Administration.” Accessed

September 25, 2023, https://www.fjc.gov/history/administration/executive-

role-judicial-administration.

Gannon v. State, 319 P.3d 1196 (Kan. 2014).

Geyh, Charles Gardner. “Paradise Lost, Paradigm Found: Redefining the Judiciary’s

Imperiled Role in Congress.” New York University Law Review 71, no. 5

(November 1996).

Hartley, Roger. “State Budget Politics and Judicial Independence: An Emerging

Crisis for the Courts as a Political Branch.” The Court Manager 18 (Winter

.

Hazard, Geoffrey C., Jr. et al.“Court Finance and Unitary Budgeting.” Yale Law

Journal 81, no. 7 (1972).

Hosford v. State, 525 So.2d 789 (Miss. 1988).

Jackson, Jeffrey. “Judicial Independence, Adequate Court Funding, and Inherent

Judicial Powers.” Maryland Law Review 52, no. 1 (1993).

Jorgensen v. Blagojevich, 811 N.E.2d 652 (Ill. 2004).

Judicial Branch of California. “The Branch Budget Process.” Accessed September

, 2023. https://www.courts.ca.gov/24153.htm.

Judicial Conference of the United States. “Strategic Plan for the Federal Judiciary.”

Washington: Judicial Conference of the United States, 2020.

Judicial Council of California. “The Strategic Plan for California’s Judicial Branch.”

July 19, 2019.

Kaplan, Robert S. and David P. Norton. “The Balanced Scorecard – Measures

that Drives Performance.” Harvard Business Review (February 1992). https://

hbr.org/1992/01/the-balanced-scorecard-measures-that-drive-performance-2.

Koranda, Stephen. “2015 KS State of the State Speech Touches on Taxes, School

Funding.” NPR. January 16, 2015. https://kansaspublicradio.org/statehouse-

news/2015-01-16/2015-ks-state-of-the-state-speech-touches-on-taxes-school-

funding.

Kitchenman, Andrew. “Dunleavy’s Court System Vetoes because of Abortion

Funding were Illegal, Judge Says.” Alaska Public Media. October 16, 2020.

https://alaskapublic.org/2020/10/16/dunleavys-court-system-vetoes-because-

of-abortion-funding-were-illegal-judge-says/.

Lavelle v. Koch, 617 A.2d 319 (Pa. 1992).

Matter of Alamance Cnty. Court Facilities, 405 S.E.2d 125 (N.C. 1991).

Matter of Maron v. Silver, 925 N.E.2d 899 (N.Y. 2010).

Nadeau, Joseph. “Ensuring Adequate Long-Term Funding for Courts:

Recommendations from the ABA Commission on State Court Funding.”

Judges’ Journal (Summer 2004).

National Center for State Courts. “Appellate Court Performance Measures.”

CourTools. Accessed September 25, 2023. https://www.ncsc.org/courtools/

appellate-court-performance-measures.

National Center for State Courts. “Measure 1: Access and Fairness.” Trial Court

Performance Measures, CourTools. Accessed September 25, 2023, https://

www.ncsc.org/__data/assets/pdf_file/0033/88737/M1Access-and-Fairness.pdf

National Center for State Courts. “Measure 3: Time to Disposition.” Trial Court

Performance Measures, CourTools. Accessed September 25, 2023. https://

www.ncsc.org/__data/assets/pdf_file/0014/61403/courtools_trial_measure3_

time_to_disposition_revised.pdf.

National Center for State Courts. “Principles for Judicial Administration.”

Williamsburg: NCSC, 2012. https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/

aba/administrative/tips/Court%20Funding/Principles%20for%20Judicial%20

Administration.pdf.

National Center for State Courts. “Trial Court Performance Measures.” CourTools.

Accessed September 25, 2023. https://www.ncsc.org/courtools/trial-court-

performance-measures.

National Center for State Courts. “Why Measure Performance?” Williamsburg:

NCSC, 2005. Web, https://www.ncsc.org/__data/assets/pdf_file/0012/6501/

courtools-why-we-measure.pdf

National Center for State Courts and Justice at Stake. “Funding Justice:

Strategies and Messages for Restoring Court Funding.” Williamsburg: NCSC,

https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/tips/

Court%20Funding/Funding%20Justice.pdf.

New York Unified Court System. “New York Unified Court System Budget

Fiscal Year 2024.” https://ww2.nycourts.gov/sites/default/files/document/

files/2022-11/FY2024_FINAL_JudiciaryBudget.pdf.

Nuss, Lawton. “Interview of Lawton Nuss by Richard Ross.” By Richard Ross, Kansas

Oral History Project (July 2022). https://ksoralhistory.org/wp-content/uploads/

Interview-of-Lawton-Nuss-by-Richard-Ross-downloaded-final-copy.pdf.

Puzzanghera, Jim. “Bipartisan Agreement on Budget Cuts: Scalpel is Better

than Ax.” Los Angeles Times (February 28): 2013. https://www.latimes.com/

business/la-xpm-2013-feb-28-la-fi-smart-budget-cuts-20130301-story.html.

Resnik, Judith. “Constitutional Entitlements to and in Courts: Remedial Rights

in an Age of Egalitarianism: The Childress Lecture.” St. Louis University Law

Journal 56, no. 4 (Summer 2012).

Resnik, Judith. “Managerial Judges.” Harvard Law Review 96, no. 2 (December

.

Spencer, Benjamin. “Pleading and Access to Civil Justice: A Response to Twiqbal

Apologists.” UCLA Law Review 60, no. 6 (August 2013).

Schauffler, Richard Y. “Judicial Accountability in the US State Courts: Measuring

Court Performance.” Utrecht Law Review 3, no. 1 (June 2007).

Sprigman, Jon. “Stripping the Courts’ Jurisdiction.” The American Prospect. May

, 2021. https://prospect.org/justice/stripping-the-courts-jurisdiction/.

Solomon v. State, 364 P.3d 536 (Kan. 2015).

State v. Planned Parenthood of the Great Nw., 436 P.3d 984 (Alaska 2019).

United States Courts. “Facing Fiscal Crises, Judicial Conference Charted

Steady Courts.” Published November 17, 2022. https://www.uscourts.gov/

news/2022/11/17/facing-fiscal-crises-judicial-conference-charted-steady-course

Viapiana, Federica. “Pressure on Judges: How the Budgeting System Can Impact

on Judge’s Autonomy.” Laws 7, no. 4 (2018): 38.

Webb, G. Gregg and Keith E. Whittington. “Judicial Independence, the

Power of the Purse, and Inherent Judicial Powers.” 88 (July 2004).

Judicature

West Virginia Judicial Compensation Commission. “Report of the West Virginia

Judicial Compensation Commission.” Charleston: West Virginia Judicial

Compensation Commission, 2022. https://www.wvlegislature.gov/interims/

JCC_2022_Report.pdf

Wilson, Conrad. “Head of Oregon Supreme Court calls for immediate fix to

ongoing lack of public defenders.” Oregon Public Broadcasting. July 7, 2022.

https://www.opb.org/article/2022/07/07/oregon-chief-justice-walters-calls-

for-immediate-fix-to-public-defender-crisis/.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev1015

Article Metrics

Abstract view : 67 times
PDF view : 14 times

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2024 Constitutional Review