Constitutional Retrogression in Indonesia Under President Joko Widodo's Government: What Can the Constitutional Court Do?

Abdurrachman Satrio

doi:10.31078/consrev425

Constitutional Retrogression in Indonesia Under President Joko Widodo's Government: What Can the Constitutional Court Do?

Abdurrachman Satrio

Abstract

This paper examines whether constitutional retrogression, the process through which democratically elected rulers use formal legal measures gradually to undermine democracy, has occurred in Indonesia, especially during the reign of President Joko Widodo. To this end, the paper analyzes the impact of the Widodo government's policies on three fundamental requirements of a democratic state: a democratic electoral system, rights to speech and association, and the rule of law. The paper finds that Widodo's government, in its efforts to contain the threat of Islamist populism, has indeed undermined all three of these elements to varying degrees. While Indonesia's democracy may yet be saved by the Constitutional Court, an institution that Widodo's government has until now failed to control, the Court cannot save democracy by itself. Its chances of doing so will depend on public support.

Keywords

Constitutional Court; Constitutional Retrogression; Democracy; Joko Widodo; Indonesian

Full Text:

PDF

References

Anggara (Et. Al). Catatan dan Rekomendasi ICJR terhadap beberapa ketentuan dalam RKUHP. Jakarta: Institute for Criminal Justice Reform, 2018.

Aspinall, Edward. "Twenty Years of Indonesian Democracy – How Many More?" New Mandala. Accessed 24 May 2018, http://www.newmandala.org/20-yearsreformasi/.Bass, Katherine Glenn, and Sujit Choudry. "Constitutional Review in New Democracies." The Center for Constitutional Transitions at NYU Law Briefing Paper 40, September 2013.

Bernal, Carlos. "Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment in the Case Study of Colombia: An Analysis of the Justification and Meaning of the Constitutional Replacement Doctrine." International Journal of Constitutional Law 11, no. 2 (2013).

Butt, Simon. "Indonesia's Constitutional Court: Conservative activist or strategic operator?" in The Judicialization of Politics in Asia, edited by Bjoern Dressel, 98-116. London and New York: Routledge, 2012.

Cyr, Jennifer, and Carlos Melendez. "Colombia's right-wing populist movement defeated the peace deal. Here's we know." The Washington Post, accessed 26 July 2018. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/10/04/colombias-right-wing-populist-movement-defeated-the-peacedeal-heres-how-we-know/?utm_term=.0b0442b7f46e. Constitutional Court Decision on Judicial Review Law on People's Consultative Assembly, People's Representative Assembly, Regional Representative Assembly, and Regional People's Representative Assembly, Number 16/PUU-XVI/2018 (The Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Law Number 2 Year 2018 on Second Amendment of Law Number 17 Year 2014).

Constitutional Court Decision on Judicial Review Law on General Election, Number 53/PUU-XV/2017 (The Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Law Number 7 Year 2017).

Corrias, Luigi. "Populism in a Constitutional Key: Constituent Power, Popular Sovereignty and Constitutional Identity." European Constitutional Law Review 12, no. 1 (2016).

Daly, Tom Gerald. "Democratic Decay in 2016." In Annual Review of Constitution-Building Processes: 2016, edited by International IDEA, 7-23. Stockholm: International IDEA, 2017.

---------. "Populism, Elitism and Democratic Decay in Brazil." Paper Presented at International Society of Public Law Conference, Hong Kong, 26 June 2018.

Rosalind Dixon. "Living to Fight Another Day: Judicial Deferral in Defense of Democracy." Wisconsin Law Review 683 (2016), 696.

----------, and David Landau. "Transnational Constitutionalism and Limited Doctrine of Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment." International Journal of Constitutional Law 13, no. 3 (2015).

Fombad, Charles Manga. "Strengthening constitutional order and upholding the rule of law in Central Africa: Reversing the descent toward symbolic constitutionalism." African Human Rights Law Journal 14, (2014).

Freedom House. "Freedom in the World 2018 Democracy in Crisis." Accessed 3 July 2018, https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2018.

Gammon, Liam. "Prabowo didn't just announce a presidential run." New Mandala.

Accessed 18 July 2018, http://www.newmandala.org/prabowo-didnt-justannounce-presidential-run/.

Gardbaum, Stephen. "What Makes for More or Less Powerful Constitutional Courts?" UCLA School of Law, Public Law & Legal Theory Research Paper, no. 17-37 (2017).

Government Regulation in Lieu Law Number 2 Year 2017 Amendment of Law Number 17 Year 2013 on Societal Organisation (Republic of Indonesia).

Grimm, Dieter. "How can a democratic constitution survive an autocratic majority?" Verfassungblog. Accessed 14 December 2018, https://verfassungsblog.de/howcan-a-democratic-constitution-survive-an-autocratic-majority/Hamid,

Usman, and Liam Gammon. "Jokowi Forges a Tool of Repression." New Mandala, 13 July 2017. http://www.newmandala.org/jokowi-forges-toolrepression/.

Halmai, Gabor. "Second Grade Constitutionalism? Hungary and Poland: How the EU Can and Should Cope with Illiberal Member States." In Developments in Constitutional Law, Essay in Honour of Andras Sajo, edited by Iulia Motoc, Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, Krzystof Wojtyczek, 159-177. Eleven International Publishing, 2018.

Harijanti, Susi Dwi, and Tim Lindsey. "Indonesian General election test the amended Constitution and the new Constitutional Court." International Journal of Constitutional Law 4, no. 1 (2006): 138.

Hendrianto, Stefanus. "The Rise and Fall of Historic Chief Justices: Constitutional Politics and Judicial Leadership in Indonesia." Washington International Law Journal 25, no. 3 (June 2016).

---------. "Indonesian Constitutional Conundrum: The Weak Presidency, the Strong Opposition and the Regional Election Law." Int'l J. Const. L. Blog (Oct 2014). http://www.iconnectblog.com/2014/09/indonesias-constitutionalconundrum-the-weak-presidency-the-strong-opposition-and-the-regionalelections-law/.

---------, and Fritz Siregar. "Indonesia: Development in Indonesian Constitutional Law". In 2016 Global Review of Constitutional Law, edited by Richard Albert, David Landau, Pietro Faraguna and Simon Drugda, 93-97. Boston: ICONnect-Clough Center, 2017.

Howse, Rob. "Populism and Its Enemies." Workshop on Public Law and the New Populism, Jean Monnet Center, NYU Law School, 15-16 September 2017.

Huq, Aziz, and Tom Ginsburg. "How to Lose a Constitutional Democracy." UCLA Law Review 65 (forthcoming 2018).

Ihsanuddin. "Pansus KPK Diisi Fraksi Pendukung Pemerintah, Jokowi Diminta Bersikap." Kompas.com, accessed 16 July, 2018. https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2017/07/25/12451401/pansus-kpk-diisi-fraksi-pendukung-pemerintahjokowi-diminta-bersikap.

Iskandar, Pranoto. "The Pancasila Delusion." Journal of Contemporary Asia 46, no. 4 (2016).

Indonesia 1945 Constitution.

Jacome, Jorge Gonzalez. "In Defense of Judicial Populism: Lessons from Colombia."

Verfassungblog. Accessed 27 July 2018. https://verfassungsblog.de/in-defenseof-judicial-populism-lessons-from-colombia/.

Januarius, Fabian. "Terlibat Kasus-Kasus Etik, Arief Hidayat Diminta Mundur dari Ketua MK." Kompas.com, accessed 16 July 2018. https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2018/01/25/20110941/terlibat-kasus-kasus-etik-arief-hidayat-dimintamundur-dari-ketua-mk.

Kine, Phelim. "Indonesian Religion Minister's Contradictory LGBT ‘Embrace'." Human Rights Watch. Accessed 8 October 2018. https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/12/19/indonesian-religion-ministers-contradictory-lgbt-embrace.

Landau, David. "Abusive Constitutionalism." UC Davis Law Review 189 (2013).

---------. "Populist Constitutions." The University of Chicago Law Review 85 (2018).

Law Number 2 Year 2018 on Second Amendment of Law Number 17 Year 2014

on People's Consultative Assembly, People's Representative Council, Regional Representative Council, and Regional People's Representative Council (Republic of Indonesia).

Law Number 7 Year 2017 on General Election (Republic of Indonesia).

Law Number 17 Year 2013 on Societal Organisation (Republic of Indonesia).

Law Number 24 Year 2003 on The Constitutional Court (Republic of Indonesia).

Lindsey, Tim. "Indonesia Devaluing Asian values, rewriting rule of law." In Asian Discourses of Rule of Law : Theories and implementation of rule of law in twelve Asian countries France and the U.S, edited by Randall Peerenboom, 290. London and New York: Routledge, 2004.

Mietzner, Marcus. "Political Conflict Resolution and Democratic Consolidation in Indonesia: The Role of the Constitutional Court." Journal of East Asian Studies 10 (2010).

---------. Reinventing Asian Populism: Jokowi's Rise, Democracy, and Political Contestation in Indonesia. Honolulu: East-West Center, 2015.

---------. "Fighting Illiberalism with Illiberalism: Islamic Populist and Democratic Deconsolidation in Indonesia." Pacific Affairs 21, no. 2, June (2018).

Nardi, Dominic. "Indonesia's Constitutional Court and Public Opinion." New Mandala, accessed 23 July 2018. http://www.newmandala.org/indonesiasconstitutional-court-public-opinion/.

Power, Tom. "Jokowi's authoritarian turn." New Mandala, accessed 15 October 2019. http://www.newmandala.org/jokowis-authoritarian-turn/

Robet, Robertus. "Beyond the bounds of democracy: DPR consolidates its power." Indonesia at Melbourne, February 23 2018. http://indonesiaatmelbourne.unimelb.edu.au/beyond-the-bounds-of-democracy-dpr-seeks-to-consolidateits-power/.

Sapiie, Marguerita Afra. "Constitutional Court maintains presidential threshold." Jakarta Post, accessed 05 December 2018. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2018/10/25/constitutional-court-maintains-presidential-threshold.html.

Scheppele, Kim Lane. "Autocratic Legalism." The University of Chicago Law Review 85 (2018).

----------. "Democracy by Judiciary. Or, why Courts Can be More Democratic than Parliaments." In Rethinking the Rule of Law after Communism, edited by Adam Czarnota, Martin Krygier and Wojciech Sadurski, 25-60. Budapest: Central European University Press, 2005.

Sherlock, Stephen. "Jokowi shares the blame for MD3 debacle." New Mandala, 19 March 2018. http://www.newmandala.org/jokowi-shares-blame-md3-debacle/.

Taufik, Giri Ahmad. "Proportionality Test in the 1945 Constitution: Limiting Hizbut Tahrir Freedom of Assembly." Constitutional Review 4, no. 1 (2018).

Tempo.co. "Jokowi: Perpu Ormas dibuat untuk menjaga Pancasila dan NKRI." Accessed 19 July 2018. https://nasional.tempo.co/read/1028012/jokowi-perpuormas-dibuat-untuk-menjaga-pancasila-dan-nkri.

Tempo.co. "Tjahjo: Presidential Treshold 20 Persen Bukan untuk Jegal Calon." Accessed 17 July 2018. https://nasional.tempo.co/read/892072/tjahjopresidential-threshold-20-persen-bukan-untuk-jegal-calon

The Economist. "The Economist Intelligence Unit's Democracy Index." Accessed 5 July 2018. https://infographics.economist.com/2018/DemocracyIndex/.

Tirto. "Peluang Rocky Gerung cs Menangkan Uji Materi di MK." Accessed 24

July 2018. https://tirto.id/peluang-rocky-gerung-cs-menangkan-uji-materipresidential-threshold-cMlv.

Tirto. "Pelantikan Arief Hidayat Wujud Penurunan Kualitas Hakim MK." Accessed 16 July 2018, https://tirto.id/pelantikan-arief-hidayat-wujud-penurunankualitas-hakim-mk-cGQo.

Tirto. "KPK: Hak Angket Tak Akan Hentikan Pengusutan Kasus e-KTP." Accessed

July 2018, https://tirto.id/kpk-hak-angket-tak-akan-hentikan-pengusutankasus-e-ktp-cnDY.

Tirto. "DPR Setuju Gunakan Hak Angket terhadap KPK." Accessed 16 July 2018, https://tirto.id/dpr-setuju-gunakan-hak-angket-terhadap-kpk-cnBr.

Tirto. "Peneliti Perludem: UU Pemilu bisa Menyulitkan Jokowi Sendiri." Accessed

July 2018, https://tirto.id/peneliti-perludem-uu-pemilu-bisa-menyulitkanjokowi-sendiri-cs89.

Transparency International Indonesia. "Agar Reformasi Pemberantasan Korupsi Tidak Sebatas Ekspektasi." Accessed 16 July 2018. http://ti.or.id/refleksigerakan-antikorupsi-menjawab-tantangan-20-tahun-reformasi/.

Uitz, Renata. "Constitutional Courts in Central and Eastern Europe: What Makes a Question too Political?" Juridica International XIII (2007).

Varol, Ozan. "Stealth Authoritarianism." Iowa Law Review 100 (2015).

Zoelva, Hamdan. "Negara Hukum dan Demokrasi: Peran Mahkamah Konstitusi Menegakkan Hukum dan Demokrasi." In Negara Hukum yang Berkeadilan, edited by Susi Dwi Harijanti et. al, 622-650. Bandung: Pusat Studi Kebijakan Negara Fakultas Hukum Universitas Padjadjaran, 2011.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev425